Shotton was found to have acted in defence of his friend when he knocked out Mark McDonald in Newcastle-under-Lyme, Staffordshire. The fight happened in the early hours of Sunday, June 24. The single punch 28-year-old Shotton delivered knocked McDonald out, leaving him with a cut, magistrates sitting at North Staffordshire Justice Centre heard. Shotton pleaded not guilty on the basis of self-defence following the fight with McDonald and his friend David Broomhall. McDonald and Shotton, who was with friends, had an altercation on the fringes of Torch nightclub's dancefloor. All parties were drinking on the night. McDonald and Shotton were shown on the CCTV face to face, with Shotton then punched once in the face by McDonald. Shotton said he had "never seen" McDonald before that moment and was taken by surprise. He said he "leaned in" to hear what McDonald was saying but that McDonald used the opportunity to land "a cheeky shot". Asked what McDonald said to him, Shotton replied:
"He said 'why do you think you run Stoke-on-Trent? You don't run it, I run it. Don't you know who I am?'
"I thought he was just somebody who had come over to talk about football but he was aggressive."
Mr Broomhall described that altercation as "a bit of a scuffle; handbags". Both parties ended up leaving the club within a few minutes of each other. Outside, Mr McDonald and Mr Broomhall tried to get into another nightclub called Pink when Mr Broomhall said he spotted Shotton and two friends "walking towards us". He said:
"Mr Shotton was beckoning with his arm to Mark to come over." Shotton told a different story, saying as he walked along the road
"two men started walking towards us" from across the street.
"I recognised him from earlier and thought 'he's here for round two'," he told magistrates.
"He came over to me and his body language was very aggressive. His fists were clenched and I was aware he'd struck before.
"I did it (punched him) to protect my friend because he turned towards him just at that moment."
Outside court, Shotton, who has made seven league appearances for Stoke this season, said he was
"a happy man" and that he had received