Birmingham City 0 - 1 West Ham

rss feed for news items | England News

Saturday Aug 18 2007 03:00

Alan Curbishley, West Ham's under-fire manager, finally eased the pressure on himself with the Hammers carving out their first win of the season and hopefully producing more unity in the Londoners' camp.

In a game of few real opportunities West Ham sealed the three points with a controversial 69th minute penalty from Mark Noble.

It was something of a disputed penalty as the luckless Birmingham goalkeeper, Colin Doyle, cut across Craig Bellamy as the ball was going out of play.

Newly-promoted Birmingham are now without a win from their first three games which is something of a repeat of their form when they were relegated two seasons ago.

Curbishley himself cut a lonely figure sitting alone in the stand, watching a desperate first half that struggled to come to life in the heavy rain, but his second-half appearance on the West Ham bench appeared to have the desired effect.

One bright spot for Curbishley was the form of his skipper, Matthew Upson, who was a given a rough ride by the Birmingham fans on his return to St Andrew's.

It was the sterling work of Upson which kept West Ham in the game, while the industrious Noble deservedly emerged as the Hammers matchwinner.

The expensively assembled West Ham side included their latest signing, Kieron Dyer, but he had a quiet debut against the mobile Birmingham defence.

Noble was the one player to pose any real threat to Birmingham, while Bobby Zamora carelessly wasted a couple of good goal chances in the second period.

Birmingham battled hard but their attack lacked a cutting edge and West Ham's goalkeeper, Robert Green, only had one save to make in the match when he went down low to keep out a free-kick from substitute Gary McSheffrey.

The Midlands club struggled to make an impact particularly in midfield where French international, Olivier Kapo, drifted in an out of the game. As a result, there was a serious lack of service to their strikers and his performance must be the cause of some concern.

Scottish international Garry O'Connor made his first start but the former Lokomotiv Moscow striker failed to get in a single goal attempt.

With the game drifting to a goalless draw the match was turned on its head when Doyle, who was at fault with two goals in the opening game at Chelsea, cut across Bellamy.

Referee Mark Halsey delayed his decision until the linesman indicated a penalty. Noble grabbed the ball and powered a low shot to the left of Doyle who went the wrong way.

Birmingham themselves claimed a penalty when O'Connor was pushed in the back by Zamora but on this occasion Halsey declined to consult his linesman and a frustrated Blues must have realised that it was not their day.

Doyle later atoned for his earlier mistake with two last-minute saves from Zamora and Bellamy.

  • 90
    This time it is the end! The final whistle goes and West Ham have won 3 points at St Andrew's, and City keeper Doyle wont be happy with his part in the penalty, bringing down Bellamy when he was going nowhere.
  • 90
    Everyone thinks the game is over, but the referee seems to have fooled everyone, and as the crowd leaves, Birmingham take a free-kick and carry on.
  • 88
    Green comes out and punches away the danger for West Ham.
  • 87
    Sebastian Larsson drills a shot from long range, but his effort goes jsut wide of the West Ham goal.
  • 86
    Danny Gabbidon comes on for Jonathan Spector
  • 86
    Bellamy's shot is caught in goal by Doyle, and time is running out for City.
  • 84
    Gary McSheffrey shoots direct from a free-kick and Green does well and tips the ball round the post.
  • 82
    George McCartney tries to keep the ball in the corner but he is tackled and the home fans get behind their team.
  • 80
    Birmingham are trying to squeeze pressure on the Hammers, but West Ham still on top and should be looking to start closing this game up.
  • 79
    Fabrice Muamba is replaced by Mathew Sadler for Birmingham.
  • 77
    Matthew Etherington has a free-kick but his cross from the right doesn't create any trouble in the danger area.
  • 75
    Olivier Kapo is booked for a foul on George McCartney.
  • 75
    Mehdi Nafti is replaced by Cameron Jerome.
  • 74
    Going into the final quarter of an hour, and Birmingham will need to do something major if they are to get back in this game.
  • 70
    Noble scores from the spot, and despite the way the penalty came around, West Ham do deserve their lead.
  • 70
    Sebastian Larsson shot from distance is blocked by Matthew Upson
  • 68
    Liam Ridgewell is booked for a foul on Bellamy.
  • 68
    Bellamy goes down in the box after a challenge from Colin Doyle, there seems to be minimal contact but the referee decides that it is enough to award a penalty.
  • 65
    Mikael Forssell is replaced by Gary McSheffrey as Birmingham look to change things around.
  • 65
    Despite not hitting the target as often as they should be, West Ham are certainly the team on top with the chances they are creating.
  • 63
    Zamora receives the ball from an Aton Ferdinand cross, but the West Ham striker puts his effort over the bar.
  • 61
    Noble fouls Fabrice Muamba and City are awarded a free-kick, the crowd seem a bit restless at the lack of genuine goal mouth chances in this game so far.
  • 58
    Approaching the hour mark of this game, and perhaps Steve Bruce and Alan Curbishley will start thinking about substitutions to influence this game.
  • 55
    Nafti is booked for a foul on Craig Bellamy.
  • 55
    A fair opening ten minutes in this second half, both teams looking a bit more open than they did in the first.
  • 52
    Noble shows great skill and gets the ball to Bellamy, but he fires his shot wide, Noble has certainly been impressive so far.
  • 49
    Aton Ferdinand is down, he seems a bit dazed, Hammers fans will be hoping he can run this off.
  • 48
    A Zamora chance from the edge of the box after an Etherington corner, but the effort goes over the bar.
  • 47
    Mullins fires in a shot 20 yards out, but Radhi Jaidi does well and gets himself in the way to block.
  • 45
    The game restarts, and there were signs in the first half that this game can certainly produce some moments of quality in the second 45.
  • 45
    The referee blows his whistle and both teams go into the break having not created many chances of note, though West Ham will still be thinking of the penalty thay could have had after a foul on Dyer early on.
  • 45
    Radhi Jaidi has a great shot from 12 yards, but the effort is well saved by Robert Green.
  • 45
    Jonathan Spector is booked after a foul on Sebastian Larsson.
  • 43
    Noble puts in a good inawinging corner, but Colin Doyle comes out and claims well.
  • 42
    Referee Halsey has awarded alot of free-kicks this half, but in a game of few chances, it creates a possiblity of either side creating something from a set piece.
  • 39
    Comming into the final five minutes of this first half, and both sides will not want to lose a goal now after keeping things so tight.
  • 36
    Both sides have certainly uped their performances in the game, and chances are starting to come, there's hope yet for the St Andrew's faithful.
  • 35
    Stuart Parnaby is booked for a foul on George McCartney.
  • 34
    Fabrice Muamba, after a good counter attack, is in space, but he takes an age to control the ball and cant make anything out of the chance.
  • 31
    Noble has the chance to shoot from a free-kick, but his shot hits the wall.
  • 31
    Half an hour gone and neither side has had much to shout about, the fans are hoping that this changes very quickly.
  • 29
    Zamora looks like he goes to shoot from the free-kick, but he cleverly slips the ball to Noble, but Nafti spots the danger and gets the tackle in.
  • 26
    Birmingham though, counter-attack, and with a dangerous ball put into the box, Mikael Forssell just cant quite reach it and a good passage of play there.
  • 25
    Noble has a free-kick from long range, it goes under the wall and hits the post!
  • 23
    Bellamy and Zamara between them have alot of pace, and the Hammers should be looking to perhaps utilise this, but at the moment, that hasn't been happining.
  • 20
    Neither side haven't been able to find that killer instinct yet, both sides are stringing together some good passes, but neither team has yet been able to find that final ball.
  • 17
    Matthew Upson will be looking to impress today as he plays against his former club, and so far he, along with his team mates, have kept out Birmingham.
  • 14
    Parnaby has a good effort from 20 yards after he found some space, unfortuantely for the game, that has been the best chance so far.
  • 10
    The crowd are quiet and the game has yet to really get going, but all it takes is one moment of magic to change a game.
  • 7
    Dyer goes down in the box after a good ball in from Bellamy, but the referee waves play on.
  • 6
    Hayden Mullins is booked for a foul on Sebastian Larsson
  • 5
    Neither side has been able to create an early chance as the game starts in a relatively slow tempo.
  • 2
    A couple of milestones in today's game, Parnaby makes his 100th career appearance while Zamora makes his 300th!
  • 0
    Mark Halsey is the man in charge today at St Andrew's, and both teams will be looking to register their first win of the Premiership campaign.
  • 0
    Dyer makes his debut for the Hammers but Scott Parker and Lucas Neill are out as West Ham begin with: Green, Spector, Ferdinand, Upson, McCartney, Dyer, Noble, Mullins, Etherington, Bellamy, Zamora
  • 0
    Olivier Kapo shakes off an injury and starts, but Queudrue, Johnson,Taylor, Saddler and Schmitz are out as Birmingham start with: Doyle, Parnaby, Jaidi, Ridgewell, Kelly, Larsson, Muamba, Nafti, Kapo, O'Connor, Forssell

Statistics

Birmingham City
Shots on target 3
Shots off target 3
Shots off bar/post 0
Fouls 16
Offsides 1
Corners 9

West Ham
Shots on target 6
Shots off target 7
Shots off bar/post 1
Fouls 15
Offsides 6
Corners 5

See Live Commentary