- Richards (56)
- Date:2009-03-22
- Kick-off:15:00
- Venue:City of Manchester Stadium
- Attendance:43017
- Referee:Tanner, S
Live Commentary
90mins
FULL TIME MAN CITY 1-0 SUNDERLAND: Micah Richards scores the only goal of the game as City made hard work of winning against a Sunderland side who were down to ten men after just 15 minutes when George McCartney was red carded.
90mins
Shaun Wright-Phillips is the third City player booked for dissent on this occasion.
90mins
A free kick for Sunderland is taken by Andy Reid into the City area but the ball is cleared by the home side.
90mins
Sunderland clear the corner and have four minutes of stoppage time to try and grab a share of the spoils.
90mins
Craig Bellamy plays in Robinho who tries to twist and turn in the area before playing in Gelson Fernandes and his effort is touched behind by Marton Fulop.
89mins
The corner is played short by Blumer Elano to Javier Garrido. He knocks it back to Blumer Elano whose cross eludes three defenders and almost lets in Robinho who can't convert.
89mins
Blumer Elano gets forward and hits an effort which Marton Fulop manages to finger tip over the cross bar for a corner to City.
87mins
From the resulting free kick Sunderland win a corner down the left hand side. Carlos Edwards plays it in to the centre but Danny Collins falls and heads it out for a goal kick.
87mins
Gelson Fernandes has only been on the pitch a few minutes and is booked for a crunching tackle on Dean Whitehead.
86mins
Sunderland have enjoyed a great spell of presure in recent minutes and they could still get something here against all the odds.
84mins
Gelson Fernandes is the third and final change for City as Vincent Kompany is going off.
83mins
The Sunderland corner comes into the centre and the ball almost ends up in the net off defender Nedum Onuoha. From the second corner Sunderland get a chance through Grant Leadbitter but his effort is straight at Shay Given.
83mins
Micah Richards is forced off due to an injury here so Javier Garrido is the new man on the field for City.
81mins
Sunderland are screaming for a penalty after Danny Collins put the ball into the area it came off Nedum Onuoha. But a corner is all they get from the referee.
80mins
Djibril Cisse tries to play in Andy Reid but Richard Dunne does well to get in a tackle and gives a corner away. The ball is played in by Carlos Edwards but cleared by Vincent Kompany.
79mins
Andy Reid is the fifth Sunderland man to be booked now for a foul on Micah Richards, while they have also had a red card.
77mins
City win a corner off Anton Ferdinand. It is taken by Blumer Elano but it is cleared initially, before the ball back goes out for a throw in.
77mins
Sunderland are still competing here and they will stay hopeful if they can keep it 1-0 for as long as possible.
75mins
Grant Leadbitter is the latest Sunderland player into the book now for dissent after complaining after a foul was given against him.
74mins
Djibril Cisse's first touch sees him give the ball away as City break forwards but an offside flag is up against Craig Bellamy.
73mins
A second change for Sunderland with Andy Reid coming on to replace Steed Malbranque in midfield.
73mins
Djibril Cisse is on for Sunderland with Kenwyne Jones going off.
72mins
Phil Bardsley is back on now and he wins a corner off Pablo Zabaleta. Carlos Edwards plays it in but City manage to clear.
71mins
Phil Bardsley has had to go off the field with a bang to his head as City take the corner but it was taken short by Blumer Elano and Robinho's effort fails to hit the target.
69mins
Shaun Wright-Phillips manages to get a ball into the middle from the right and Robinho cannot convert the chance as Phil Bardsley goes down with a knock after putting off the Brazilian hitman.
67mins
Marton Fulop manages to hack the ball away despite Robinho breathing down his neck. Risky stuff from the Sunderland keeper.
65mins
Valeri Bojinov is going off for a rest after a decent run out on his return to the City side and the dangerous Craig Bellamy is on to replace him.
62mins
Kenwyne Jones goes down inside the City area but the referee says no penalty there despite some contact with the big striker.
60mins
Back to the other end and Blumer Elano somehow fails to make it 2-0 when he picks up a Micah Richards cross in the area but fires wide from six yards.
58mins
Grant Leadbitter tries to get Sunderland back on level terms but Shay Given saves his effort at the second attempt.
56mins
MAN CITY 1-0 SUNDERLAND: Kenwyne Jones fouls Valeri Bojinov inside the Sunderland half. Blumer Elano takes the kick and MICAH RICHARDS gets the final touch to put the ball over the line and City are in front.
55mins
Micah Richards gets to the byline and crosses for Shaun Wright-Phillips who fires his effort well over the bar. His finishing has let him down badly so far in this game.
54mins
City are now enjoying the majority of the possession but the Sunderland defence is holding firm.
53mins
Dean Whitehead's overhead kick almost plays in Kenwyne Jones but the ball runs through to former Newcastle keeper Shay Given who is getting some stick off the Sunderland fans behind him.
51mins
The ball rebounds to Shaun Wright-Phillips on the edge of the area but his effort at goal is blocked and City are denied again.
49mins
The flag is up for offside here as Blumer Elano tries to play in Micah Richards so Sunderland breathe a sigh of relief and get a free kick.
47mins
Calum Davenport goes down in the area looking for a penalty after a set-piece from Phil Bardsley and instead he earns a yellow card for diving.
46mins
Carlos Edwards already forces Richard Dunne into conceding a very early corner but City manage to defend it as Robinho hits the deck easily looking for a free kick.
46mins
The second half is underway and City will be desperate to break down the ten men of Sunderland, who will probably be happy to try and hang on for a point or maybe nick a win on the break.
45mins
HALF TIME MAN CITY 0-0 SUNDERLAND: An eventful first half comes to a close with it somehow staying goalless after Sunderland were reduced to ten men on 15 minutes with George McCartney getting sent off before Robinho missed a penalty for City.
45mins
It is Sunderland who are finishing the half the stronger with several crosses into the City area but they fail to test Shay Given.
45mins
Just two minutes of stoppage time which is surprising as the penalty incident took longer than that to sort out earlier in this half.
44mins
Micah Richards is lucky not to be booked after kicking the ball away after conceding a free kick. Sunderland put the free kick into the City area and it is headed clear by Richard Dunne.
42mins
Shaun Wright-Phillips almost carves an opening for himself but Danny Collins manages to get a tackle in to prevent a cross into the area.
41mins
We are approaching the half time interval and Sunderland will be delighted to go in at the break on level terms having done well since going down to ten men.
39mins
Carlos Edwards plays another Sunderland corner into the centre but the ball is again cleared by the defence.
38mins
City go forwards again and Blumer Elano's shot bounces up in front of Marton Fulop who gathers the ball.
37mins
Grant Leadbitter takes the kick but it smacks off the wall and when Phil Bardsley plays a cross back in Kenwyne Jones commits a foul.
37mins
Sunderland get a free kick in a great spot as Richard Dunne fouls Steed Malbranque just outside the area inside the D.
36mins
Nedum Onuoha tackles Kenwyne Jones and gives a corner away so a chance for Sunderland now. Carlos Edwards plays it in but Vincent Kompany and Valeri Bojinov combine to clear.
35mins
A promising move by Sunderland as Carlos Edwards gets to the byline and crosses in but Danny Collins commits a foul in the area as he goes for the ball.
33mins
Micah Richards wins a corner off Danny Collins for City. Blumer Elano plays it in from the right but it is headed over Valeri Bojinov.
32mins
Kenwyne Jones has a pop at the City goal but it fails to really test Shay Given who gathers comfortably.
30mins
Vincent Kompany gets the ball off Valeri Bojinov and hits an effort over the top of Marton Fulop's goal as City press again.
28mins
To be fair to Sunderland they are not going into ultra defnsive mode after going a man down, although City get forward again only for the final ball to go out for a goal kick.
26mins
City lost their rhythm after that penalty miss but are now looking to get their game back on track.
24mins
A ball into the area from Shaun Wright-Phillips is headed at goal by Valeri Bojinov but it is straight at Marton Fulop.
23mins
Carlos Edwards tries his luck from around the edge of the area and his shot fizzes just over the crossbar.
22mins
It has been a crazy opening 20 minutes or so of this game here and City will be wondering how they are not two goals ahead against their ten man opponents.
20mins
Unbelievable stuff here as Marton Fulop has guessed right and saves Robinho's very poor penalty so Sunderland are still on level terms.
19mins
Anton Ferdinand is the second Sunderland man who was booked for complaining about the penalty award.
19mins
Valeri Bojinov is also booked as the City man got involved in the arguments after the penalty decision.
19mins
Sunderland's Phil Bardsley is booked for complaining about that penalty decision.
19mins
Steed Malbranque has caught Micah Richards inside the area and it is a penalty now to Man City. Things are going from bad to worse here for Sunderland.
17mins
Sunderland try and get an attack going now with a ball in just deflecting behind off Kenwyne Jones and out for a goal kick.
16mins
Daryl Murphy is sacrificed here as his return to the side is short-lived with Calum Davenport making his Sunderland debut in the defence for Sunderland.
16mins
Valeri Bojinov takes the free kick left-footed but it just clears the Sunderland bar.
15mins
George McCartney is sent off for a professional foul for preventing Shaun Wright-Phillips a goalscoring opportunity. A nightmare for Sunderland who are down to ten men - this was later rescinded by the FA.
14mins
City have dominated here and Shaun Wright-Phillips looks to be hauled down by George McCartney right on the edge of the area here.
12mins
Sunderland win a free kick inside the City half but the ball towards Danny Collins does not reach him and City try to get forward again.
10mins
Man City are enjoying a good spell of possession here as they look to get an early goal with Shaun Wright-Phillips at the centre of most things.
8mins
Shaun Wright-Phillips has missed a fantastic chance to open the scoring as he goes through one-on-one but lifts the ball over Marton Fulop and wide of the post.
8mins
Blumer Elano goes on a mazy run past four players and tries to play in Robinho but the ball was too heavy and it's goal kick to Sunderland.
7mins
George McCartney concedes the first corner of the game which Blumer Elano plays in but Nedum Onuoha heads it behind under pressure from Kenwyne Jones.
6mins
It has been a lively start here and Sunderland look like they will try and sit back and nick something on the break, but no real chances just yet.
4mins
Daryl Murphy takes advantage of a mistake by Shaun Wright-Phillips and tries to play the ball into Kenwyne Jones but Nedum Onuoha does enough to put off the Black Cats striker.
3mins
Sunderland go on the counter-attack through Steed Malbranque who plays in Grant Leadbitter but he cannot get his cross in to find Kenwyne Jones in the area as Shay Given gathers.
2mins
Daryl Murphy gives an early fre ekick away for a nudge on Micah Richards as he looks to get forwad for City. Blumer Elano puts it into the area but Sunderland clear the danger.
0mins
The game at Eastlands is underway with City aiming for a win which would virtually guarantee their Premier League safety and see them three points off a European spot, while Sunderland can move six points clear of the drop zone with a win.
0mins
Sunderland starting XI: Fulop, Bardsley, Collins, Ferdinand, McCartney, Edwards, Whitehead, Leadbitter, Murphy, Malbranque, Jones.
0mins
Sunderland are boosted by the return of defender Anton Ferdinand for the game at City, while boss Ricky Sbragia has opted to pick Kenwyne Jones as his lone front man, leaving Djibril Cisse on the bench.
0mins
Man City starting XI: Given, Richards, Onuoha, Dunne, Zabaleta, Wright-Phillips, Elano, De Jong, Kompany, Robinho, Bojinov.
0mins
Wayne Bridge and Stephen Ireland, injured in the Uefa Cup clash against Aalborg on Thursday, are replaced by Elano and Nigel de Jong.
0mins
Craig Bellamy, who has just recovered from his own knee trouble, is handed a place on the bench with Ched Evans as Robinho starts in attack.
0mins
Mark Hughes hands striker and long-term knee injury victim Valeri Bojinov his first start since August 2007 for Manchester Citys visit of Sunderland to Eastlands.
Match Preview
Manchester City are back in Premier League action with the visit of Sunderland to Eastlands following their latest foray into Europe.
City may have little to play for domestically as they are unlikely to be relegated or secure enough points to finish in the European places this season.
But with manager Mark Hughes promising major squad changes at the end of the season, he has effectively ensured his players will remain on their toes until their summer breaks begin.
Last weekend's meek 1-0 defeat at the hands of Chelsea - in which £32million Brazilian Robinho was again hauled off after failing to impress - will not be tolerated by Hughes.
"Although we've brought players in, we haven't shed a great deal. We'll have to do that because we have to have a manageable squad," he warned.
Hughes could welcome back Craig Bellamy following the Wales striker's month-long absence with a knee injury.
Belgian midfielder Vincent Kompany is available again following a toe injury, while Dutch enforcer Nigel de Jong will return after being cup-tied in Europe.
City may also be buoyed by the fact that their one away win this season came in a 3-0 success over Sunderland at the Stadium of Light in August.
Sunderland manager Ricky Sbragia has admitted they have been dragged back into the relegation dogfight following a disappointing run of results.
The Black Cats lost 2-1 to Wigan Athletic last weekend as their winless run stretched to four games and they are now just three points above the relegation zone.
Sbragia admitted wins are needed quickly to avoid a drama becoming a crisis and he may be tempted to shuffle his pack at the City of Manchester Stadium.
His strikeforce of Kenwyne Jones and Djibril Cisse has looked out of sorts in recent weeks, which could open the door for the likes of David Healy and Darryl Murphy.
Kieran Richardson is likely to return in midfield following his suspension last weekend, while Anton Ferdinand is confident of shaking off a hamstring problem in time to feature.
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Defender Micah Richards came to Manchester City's rescue and spared them acute embarrassment as they struggled to defeat stubborn ten-man Sunderland at Eastlands.
The right-back was City's match winner as he found the net with a rare goal - his first in more than two-and-a-half years.
City laboured to this victory despite having an extra man for 76 minutes after George McCartney's early sending off.
But City struggled to take advantage of their extra man with an unimpressive display which followed on from their defeat in Denmark three days earlier when they needed a penalty shoot-out to overcome Aalborg in the UEFA Cup.
City were without Wayne Bridge, Stephen Ireland and Felipe Caicedo, who were all injured in the midweek match.
And the absence of the injured trio clearly disrupted City, who looked far from a team with hopes of challenging for a European place.
The match exploded to life in the 14th minute when Sunderland had left-back McCartney sent off for pulling back Shaun Wright-Phillips as he burst through on goal.
Referee Steve Tanner failed to spot the offence but was alerted by an eagle-eyed assistant.
Tanner was the centre of further controversy minutes later when he awarded City a penalty after he judged Richards had been fouled by Steed Malbranque as he burst into the area following a rampaging run from defence.
City failed to capitalise as Robinho's weakly struck spot-kick was easily saved by Sunderland's Hungarian keeper Marton Fulop.
Mark Hughes' side went on to create numerous clear-cut chances but were let down by wayward finishing in the goalless opening period.
It was a similar frustrating story early in the second half until Richards finally broke the deadlock in the 57th minute.
He leapt salmon-like at the far post to head Elano's free-kick with the ball clearly over the line before Robinho applied a final touch.
Elano wasted a glorious chance two minutes later to seal victory as he amazingly shot wide from seven yards after another brilliant forward run from Richards.
Sunderland made a brave fist of the game and there were spells in the second half when City had to defend doggedly to preserve their advantage.
But in the closing stages, Sunderland were forced to take risks in their pursuit of an equalising goal and left themselves open at the back.
City were denied a second and clinching goal on three separate occasions by the brilliance of Fulop, who made super saves to deny Elano, substitute Gelson Fernandes and Robinho.
Manchester City Team
Sunderland Team
Manchester City | Sunderland |
Corners
| 7 | 8 |
Fouls
| 16 | 12 |
Goal attempts
| 19 | 6 |
Shots off target
| 8 | 1 |
Offsides
| 2 | 0 |



90mins
Robinho is again guilty of missing a chance to score as Marton Fulop again denies him with a great save as he concedes a corner.