- Scharner (25)
- Geovanni (1)
- Date:2007-12-01
- Kick-off:15:00
- Venue:The JJB Stadium
- Attendance:18614
- Referee:Riley, M
Live Commentary
90mins
FT:Wigan 1-1 Man City: It is hard to believe there were so few chances in this game as both sides were lively and a draw is probably a fair result in the end.
90mins
Ireland scored a dramatic late winner last week and almost repeats the trick with a back-heeled effort that rolls just wide.
90mins
There is a fair bit of stoppage time going to be played here, especially after that red card.
87mins
Mario Melchiot with a vicious looking two footed lunge on Ireland has been dismissed, although in the Dutchman's defence he did appear to get some of the ball.
85mins
Michael Ball is another play that finds himself in the referee's notebook as he brings down Scharner.
84mins
Superb run from young Etuhu as he sprints past three defenders to get to the byline before cutting it back into the area but no-one arrives and Wigan clear.
83mins
Hamann has been very quiet today when Eriksson would have been looking for him to use his experience, in the absence of the injured Elano, to open up the Wigan defence.
80mins
Watching this must be so frustrating for Wigan and City fans! Both teams have been playing decent stuff until the final third when it has broken down almost every single time. At the moment you get the feeling they are happy to take a point each.
78mins
Rolando Bianchi is on - to the delight of the travelling support - as he replaces the disappointing Samaras.
76mins
Taylor now robs Ball on the edge of the visitors penalty area and is in on goal but the referee has awarded a free-kick and in all honesty that is a very poor decision.
74mins
Paul Scharner is the latest to go into the book as he brings down Dietmar Hamann in midfield.
73mins
Jason Koumas has sort of drifted out of this but the ball drops to him now in the area and only a superb sliding block from Dunne prevents him testing Isaksson.
70mins
Having been looking the more likely, Wigan have now stopped playing football and are just lumping it into channels which is just giving Man City easy possession.
69mins
Geovanni has been running the channels all day and is clearly tired and he is now replaced by young Kelvin Etuhu.
67mins
At the moment the game is being heavily disrupted by a number of petty fouls which is breaking up any chance of flowing football.
64mins
It is still a lively game but the quality of play is still lacking. This is a strange one really as there are so many threatening situations but few attempts on goal.
62mins
Titus Bramble is not having his best of days and one more bad challenge will see it complete as he picks up a yellow card for a foul on Samaras.
60mins
The attendance figures have just been announced and City fans make up over a quarter of today's crowd. Is that great support from them or poor support for Wigan?
59mins
Ryan Taylor with one of his very first touches forces Isaksson into a good diving stop with a stinging left-foot volley.
58mins
Koumas initially does brilliantly as he fakes to shoot before cutting to the byline but unfortunately he can't wrap his foot round the ball and it skews out of play behind the goal.
54mins
It appears that Wigan are going to move Koumas in behind Bent with Taylor occupying the right wing slot, this could work well as Koumas has looked in good touch.
52mins
An interesting change though from Bruce as he replaces Heskey with a defender, in the shape of right-back Ryan Taylor.
51mins
A shame here for Emile Heskey and Wigan because Bent plays a lovely ball into the box but the England man pulls up and looks do have done damage to his hamstring.
50mins
City are playing the better football but they have probably created less opportunities to have a go at goal than Wigan.
48mins
Geovanni and Ireland combine neatly on the edge of the box and unfortunately for City the ball bobbles just as the latter attempts a strike on goal.
46mins
Both sides are unchanged as we begin the second half hoping for more quality to match the sizeable effort.
45mins
Both sides have been lively but without showing too much in the final third. Wigan recovered well from that horrendous start but, apart from the goals, there has been very little goalmouth action so far.
45mins
Kilbane hurls in a long throw and everyone leaves it and Marcus Bent is inches away from tapping into the net.
45mins
Two minutes of added time are to be played.
44mins
Melchiot is advancing with gusto down the right hand side and Hamann scythes him down to pick up the first booking of the game.
42mins
Petrov curls in a free-kick from the right hand side and Dunne goes in with Heskey for it but it comes off the big centre half and out for a goal kick.
39mins
There are very few goals around the Premier League this afternoon and considering the number of real chances it is hard to believe we have had both of them here.
35mins
Garrido hasn't recovered sufficiently from that knock he took earlier and he will now be replaced by Michael Ball.
32mins
Koumas is beginning to enjoy himself and he almost threads Valencia in behind but Richards intercepts well although he then gifts possession back and Valencia almost finds Heskey coming in.
30mins
The game is very open and its hard to believe that - apart from the goals - there has been so little goalmouth action.
27mins
That has perked up the crowd again and they will hope to drive their team on now and see if they can get in front before the break.
24mins
There is the equaliser! Jason Koumas gets to the byline and chips it to the far post where Scharner arrives to head it into the net.
22mins
There is very little to comment on unfortunately with both teams playing some very poor football in this first half, we can only hope things improve.
20mins
Garrido has taken quite a bad knock and been down for a few minutes now but he is walking off the pitch so it seems he will return.
17mins
Man City have set themselves out to attack today anf they are not actually playing too well and Jason Koumas looks like he may find a lot of room in the gap on City's right hand side.
13mins
That goals certainly took the new manager spice out of Wigan who are trying to force their way back into this game but the tempo is slow and the passing inaccurate.
10mins
Landzaat has got into an advanced position to try and whip a ball in for Bent and Heskey to attack but Richard Dunne makes a very good block to deny them.
7mins
Geovanni could be in behind Bramble again here but this time the centre half uses his strength well and holds off the Brazilian.
4mins
Man City cannot believe their luck and are enjoying some decent possession in early stages and teh lively home crowd have been silenced completely.
1mins
What a start for City! Titus Bramble makes a horrible mistake in failing to clear a simple ball and Geovanni runs through to round the keeper and put it in with just 30 seconds on the clock.
0mins
We are underway at the JJB.
0mins
Man City: Isaksson, Corluka, Dunne, Richards, Garrido, Ireland, Hamann, Gelson, Geovanni, Petrov, Samaras
0mins
Wigan: Kirkland, Melchiot, Bramble, Boyce, Kilbane, Valencia, Scharner, Landzaat, Koumas, Bent, Heskey
0mins
City have recovered well from the hammering they took at Stamford Bridge but they needed a wonder strike from Stephen Ireland to beat Reading last time out.
0mins
Wigan defended stoutly for 80 minutes against table-topping Arsenal before being undone twice late-on but that showed a good upturn in their form which had been nothing short of terrible.
0mins
Sven Goran-Eriksson brings his Manchester City side to the JJB as Steve Bruce takes charge of the Latics for the first time.
Match Preview
Steve Bruce gets his second spell in charge of Wigan Athletic underway with a derby clash with Manchester City at the JJB Stadium.
Bruce has finally tied up his move from Birmingham City and is looking forward to the challenge of trying to lift the Latics away from relegation danger.
On his appointment by Wigan, Bruce said: "It will be difficult, but I'm confident I can do the job and keep us in the Premier League.
"It is a vital time between now and Christmas. It will determine our season. If we can get two or three wins under our belt we will give ourselves a chance.
"I believe I can turn it around. There are about eight teams that are struggling and my aim is make sure we retain our status."
Bruce has now been joined by number two Eric Black, as the duo seek to end a run of eight straight league defeats, including a 2-0 reverse at Arsenal last time out.
Bruce at least has an empty treatment room, with only back-up keeper Carlo Nash currently out of action.
Visitors City have few of the problems being faced by Wigan at the moment, with Sven-Goran Eriksson still enjoying a honeymoon period in charge of the Citizens.
Last weekend's 2-1 win over Reading saw Vedran Corluka and Elano suffer hamstring injuries, while Emile Mpenza (thigh) and Richard Dunne (calf) both picked up knocks and Elano has now been ruled out of the weekend action.
Valeri Bojinov (knee) is still some way off a return to action, while Darius Vassell will be absent for a couple of weeks, also due to a knee problem.
The win over the Royals came courtesy of Stephen Ireland's last-gasp volley, with Eriksson saying afterwards: "We won thanks to the spirit in the team. Without that spirit we wouldn't have won the game.
"You can see how tight it is now and we are third still and very happy with that. We are playing rather good football as well."
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Steve Bruce's reign got off to an encouraging start as ten-man Wigan showed their fighting qualities to stop the rot after eight straight defeats and deny Manchester City the chance to move ahead of rivals United in the Premier League table.
But the former Birmingham boss had to endure an instantly forgettable first minute when City were gifted the lead before they battled back to level before half-time.
And he could have lived without the late red card for skipper Mario Melchiot who now faces a three-match ban.
Sven-Goran Eriksson's side was missing influential Brazilian star Elano who picked up a hamstring injury in training, but Geovanni was back in the starting line-up.
Wigan had Chris Kirkland, Antonio Valencia and Melchiot back after injury and Emile Heskey, who was on the bench at Arsenal last week, was in from the off partnering Marcus Bent up front with Antoine Sibierski injured.
The welcome applause for Bruce had hardly died down when City grabbed the lead after a terrible blunder by Titus Bramble.
The big centre-back made a total mess of getting the ball clear when there appeared to be no danger.
The slip let Geovanni in and the Brazilian nipped round Kirkland to slot it into the empty net after just 35 seconds to make it a nightmare start for the Latics and their new manager.
But Wigan bounced back to level it up when Jason Koumas pounced on Vedran Corluka's clearing header to pick out the unmarked Paul Scharner with the cross, and the Austrian midfielder headed in the equaliser.
The Latics threatened again just before half-time when Koumas hammered one over the bar and a Kevin Kilbane throw-in bounced dangerously in the box, but no-one took advantage of the chance.
Ryan Taylor replaced Heskey and the former Tranmere player went close to firing Wigan into the lead.
Scharner set up the strike and City keeper Andreas Isaksson reacted superbly to push it wide.
Wigan had a handball appeal against Micah Richards turned down as Valencia chased into the box and there was more controversy when Michael Ball was robbed of possession just inside the area, and ref Mike Riley blew for a free-kick.
But the match ended on a sour note when the Latics were reduced to ten men for the last three minutes after Melchiot was sent off for a two-footed challenge on Stephen Ireland.
And the Latics were denied again in stoppage time when the ball appeared to strike Kelvin Etuhu on the hand inside the area.
Wigan Athletic Team
Manchester City Team
Wigan Athletic | Manchester City |
Corners
| 2 | 4 |
Fouls
| 13 | 10 |
Goal attempts
| 5 | 4 |
Shots off target
| 1 | 3 |
Offsides
| 2 | 2 |



90mins
The home fans are appealing for a penalty as Etuhu controls the ball in his own area as they think he used his arm but the referee gives nothing.