- Carrick (90)
- Vassell (25), Benjani (45)
- Date:2008-02-10
- Kick-off:13:30
- Venue:Old Trafford
- Attendance:75970
- Referee:Webb, H
Live Commentary
90mins
The whistle goes! City are good value for that win
90mins
Desperate stuff from United, but Vidic is offside
90mins
Michael Carrick pulls one back, rifling home from the edge of the area
90mins
Three minutes will be added. Giggs finds Scholes but he is offside
89mins
Scholes shoots over after some neat play by Carrick and Ronaldo. The homes fans are streaming out of the exits
87mins
Martin Petrov makes way for Javier Garrido
85mins
Van der Sar launches a long ball but it won't fall for Vidic, who is playing as a centre forward
83mins
Sun Jihai replaces Dietmar Hamann
83mins
Ji-Sung Park skips clear and Brown's cross is headed behind by Dunne. Michael Ball clears the corner
81mins
Corner to United as Onuoha slips in the corner. Bundled behind and a goal kick is given
79mins
City are edging to their first league double over United in 38 years
78mins
Hart is left standing as Giggs fires wide from distance
77mins
United need something special as the Blues are starting to look comfortable
75mins
City respond with Felipe Caicedo replacing fellow debutant Benjani Mwaruwari
72mins
Last throw of United's dice: Owen Hargreaves and Michael Carrick replace Luis de Abreu Anderson and John O'Shea
71mins
There is no passing Dunne and Richards. They have been resolute in the heart of the Citizens' defence
70mins
City might think that they have weathered the storm; the home crowd is quieter as the clock ticks down
68mins
United's turn to force a corner. Time running out for the home side. Cleared to Ji-Sung Park, who shoots wide from 35 yards
67mins
City break at speed, Hamann finding Petrov who has his cross intercepted by Vidic. A flurry of three corners follows. Van der Sar clings on and launches another attack
65mins
Richard Dunne clears behind for a corner as Tevez prepares to pull the trigger. Cleared by City
64mins
First change: Ji-Sung Park replaces the disappointing Luis Carlos Nani
62mins
Ronaldo collects a Scholes pass and fires narrowly wide of the left post from outside the area
61mins
Backs-to-the-wall stuff from City, with Ball and Dunne making good blocks inside the area
59mins
A good fast break from City, Petrov and Benjani firing in shots after Ferdinand again conceded possession
57mins
John O'Shea is booked for a foul on Darius Vassell
55mins
United have it in the net but offside! Tevez slots home but the flag was up early when Scholes had the initial shot. United are pouring forward at every opportunity
54mins
Wes Brown slips in Ronaldo, whose cross evades everyone. Tevez and Nani were left waiting
53mins
Richards again challenges Ronaldo, conceding a corner. That came from a long ball - United are definitely trying to get the ball forward quickly. The corner nearly falls to Vidic, but Hart smothers at his feet
52mins
City are looking slick on the counter, utilising the pace of Petrov and Vassell in wide areas
50mins
Ryan Giggs finds Tevez but Micah Richards is over quickly to challenge
48mins
United are already showing more urgency, pressing the ball and shifting it early when in possession
46mins
Good 30 yard strike from Hamann, but Van der Sar saves easily. Quick release to Ronaldo, but City clear
45mins
Unlike last week, Sir Alex Ferguson has made no half time changes. City also unchanged. The second half begins
45mins
All three of United's league defeats have come when Rooney has been absent. The home side have lacked his urgency and creative spark
45mins
City have capitalised on United's poor display
44mins
Benjani scores! Petrov crosses and the debutant gets the slightest flick
43mins
Slack work from Ferdinand, who gives away possession cheaply. Petrov fires in a cross that Van der Sar only just turns away for a corner. Ronaldo slices behind for another City corner
41mins
Still not enough fluency from United as the game edges towards the break
39mins
Benjani wriggles free from Ferdinand, who went to sleep in trying to run the ball out. Petrov's corner is headed clear by Ronaldo
37mins
The Red Devils are increasing the pressure but City stand firm
35mins
Ronaldo latches onto Wes Brown's low cross, shoots first time and wins a corner. City clear and Ferdinand has his shot blocked
33mins
Ronaldo fires over... the famous dip didn't come in time
32mins
Free kick for United - definitely in Ronaldo territory
30mins
Vassell is fit to continue. Disjointed stuff from United - might they be in for more half time 'hairdryer treatment' as at Spurs last week?
28mins
City are stroking the ball around with confidence. Vassell takes a knock after contesting a high ball with John O'Shea
26mins
Good save from Hart, parrying Tevez's powerful volleyed drive. The game has exploded into life
25mins
United force a corner but cannot produce an immediate response
24mins
City score! Darius Vassell tucks home at the second attempt after good work by Benjani. United's defence was all over the place
22mins
City have now settled well and the visitors will be happy as the game reaches its quarter mark
20mins
Great interception from Rio Ferdinand, who flicks away Gelson Fernandes' cross from the advancing Benjani
17mins
Ronaldo goes down in the box under Dietmar Hamann's challenge, but no penalty
15mins
City are finding their feet and threaten through a Petrov cross that Van der Sar pounces on ahead of the lurking Benjani
14mins
Richard Dunne makes a crucial tackle on Tevez, who is released by a Ronaldo through ball
12mins
Benjani tees up Martin Petrov who fires over from 25 yards
10mins
The visitors enjoy a spell in United's half, ending with a good Michael Ball cross that is headed clear for a City throw
8mins
United have come out of the traps much faster, zipping the ball around in City's half
7mins
First chance: Carlos Tevez breaks down the right, crosses deep to Ryan Giggs who forces Joe Hart to tip over. The corner is cleared
5mins
A predictably high tempo start, with United enjoying slightly more possession
2mins
An early alarm for City as Anderson releases Ronaldo, but Micah Richards scrambles it clear
0mins
Referee Howard Webb starts the game
0mins
The minute was well-observed and the silence gives way to a scintillating atmosphere
0mins
Club wreaths are laid in the centre circle and the minute's silence begins
0mins
The players also have numbers 1-11 on their backs. They are led through a guard of honour of young players by a lone piper
0mins
Glorious sunshine greets the players, who emerge in their 1950's style kits to take part in the pre-match Munich air disaster commemorations
0mins
City have not won at Old Trafford since 1974, although they did win this season's reverse fixture, by a 1-0 scoreline
0mins
City give Benjani a debut - the former Pompey man will play as a lone striker in a 4-5-1 formation. City line-up: Hart, Onuoha, Dunne, Richards, Ball, Vassell, Ireland, Hamann, Fernandes, Petrov, Benjani
0mins
Ronaldo and Anderson have shaken off ankle knocks. United team: Van der Sar, Brown, Vidic, Ferdinand, O'Shea, Nani, Anderson, Scholes, Giggs, Ronaldo, Tevez
0mins
Team news for this special Manchester derby: both sides are missing a creative talent and a full back through suspension, Rooney and Evra for United, Elano and Corluka for City
Match Preview
Memories of the Munich air disaster have dominated the build-up to Sunday's Manchester derby, a match that could have a huge bearing on the destination of this season's Premier League title.
A minute's silence will be held at Old Trafford before the kick-off, three days after the 50th anniversary of the tragedy when BEA Flight 609 ZU crashed on take-off from Munich Airport, killing 23 people including eight United players.
Sir Alex Ferguson will be hoping his team can honour the 1958 team by producing a fine display against their local rivals and clinching their 19th win of the campaign.
United have been in imperious form at Old Trafford this term, winning 12 successive league games since being held to a goalless draw by Reading on the opening weekend of the season.
They have conceded only three goals in their 13 home games, but have been less certain on their travels and last weekend's 1-1 draw at Tottenham means they have failed to take maximum points in six of their 12 away games this term.
Ferguson will once again be without injured quartet of Louis Saha, Gary Neville, Mikael Silvestre and Ben Foster, while Wayne Rooney and Patrice Evra are suspended after picking up five yellow cards this season.
City boss Sven-Goran Eriksson could hand a debut to Benjani Mwaruwari after the striker's protracted move to Eastlands from Portsmouth was finally resolved on Tuesday.
The Zimbabwe international could play as a lone striker on Sunday as City attempt to end a poor recent run that has seen them take only two points from their last four league matches.
That run has seen them fall to seventh in the table, while last weekend's 3-1 loss to Arsenal was their first home league defeat this term.
Injured duo Nery Castillo and Michael Johnson miss out, while Elano is suspended after picking up five bookings.
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Manchester United's players of 2008 fell flat on the day Old Trafford paid a moving tribute to the victims of the Munich air disaster, as Manchester City won the derby 2-1.
It has been an emotional week for United with the 50th anniversary of the disaster falling last Wednesday.
But expectations that the United players of today would mark the event by beating neighbours City in style lay in tatters after the champions failed miserably in their task.
City had not won at Old Trafford for almost 34 years - in fact their last league double over the Red Devils was in the 1969-70 season, yet it was the Blues who played with determination.
The minute's silence for the 23 victims of the air crash was impeccably observed.
It came shortly after both teams had been led out by a lone piper and United manager Sir Alex Ferguson and his City counterpart Sven-Goran Eriksson had both laid wreaths on behalf of their clubs in the centre circle.
United, playing in a replica kit of that worn by the Busby Babes before the crash, made a bright start and came close to scoring in the seventh minute.
Nani's cross from the right was touched down by Carlos Tevez to Ryan Giggs at the far post and his blistering shot from 12yards was well tipped over by City goalkeeper Joe Hart.
City's Stephen Ireland tested United keeper Edwin Van der Sar with a far-post header from Martin Petrov's left-wing cross after a quarter of an hour, but things got even better for City in the 24th minute.
Benjani Mwaruwari, making his debut for City following his protracted move from Portsmouth, found Petrov on the left.
The Bulgarian winger guided a brilliant through ball to Ireland inside the United box from wide and, although Van der Sar blocked his effort, the ball fell to Darius Vassell on the right side of the penalty area.
Van der Sar blocked Vassell's first effort, but the rebound fell to the City striker who scored with a crisp left-foot shot from ten yards.
Hart produced a magnificent save to keep out Tevez's ferocious drive from the right edge of the City box three minutes later.
But City could sense United were below par and that a second goal was there for the taking and they made it 2-0 in the closing seconds of the first half.
Cristiano Ronaldo's clearing header on the near post from a Petrov corner fell to Ireland on the right corner of the box.
He returned the ball to Petrov, who whipped in a superb cross which went in of Benjani's shoulder eight yards from goal.
The expected United onslaught after the interval never materialised. City looked comfortable, although United netted a consolation effort seconds into injury time.
Paul Scholes threaded his pass through the middle to substitute Michael Carrick 12 yards out and he scored with a right-foot shot into the bottom corner of the City net.
Manchester United Team
Manchester City Team
Manchester United | Manchester City |
Corners
| 8 | 7 |
Fouls
| 6 | 11 |
Goal attempts
| 19 | 9 |
Shots off target
| 10 | 2 |
Offsides
| 7 | 0 |



90mins
Excellent display from City, who end their recent slide in style. A day to remember for United became a day to forget