- Gosling (90)
- Robinho (35), Ireland (54)
- Date:2009-04-25
- Kick-off:15:00
- Venue:Goodison Park
- Attendance:37791
- Referee:Wiley, A
Live Commentary
90mins
Full-Time: EVERTON 1-2 MAN CITY. The final whistle goes after a dramatic finish at Goodison.
90mins
EVERTON 1-2 MAN CITY. Sloppy defending from City and they are punished as GOSLING ghosts into the penalty area and finds the top corner with his left-foot.
90mins
Seven minutes of injury time to come in a second half riddled with injuries.
90mins
City lead another break away headed by Ireland and Robinho and the Irishman tried to lift the ball over the onrushing Tim Howard but got too much on it and sent it over the bar.
88mins
Elano goes down with a knee injury. It doesn't look serious but Mark Hughes takes no chances and replaces him with Ched Evans.
85mins
Stephen Ireland makes a surging run towards the heart of the Everton defence before sliding the ball to Robinho who fires a shot at goal but it just shaves the post with Howard beaten.
83mins
Martin Petrov comes on for the last few minutes in place of Caceido who has worked tirelessly today.
82mins
The free-kick comes in from Pienaar and the Dunne rises to head clear but directs it towards his own goal and is relieved to see it fly just wide of the upright. Nearly an own goal from the former Everton man.
82mins
Fernandes is booked. Its not clear whether it was for a foul or for dissent.
80mins
City win the ball in the middle of the park and Caceido finds Ireland who then turns the ball into the path of Elano. The Brazilian shoots from a tight angle but can only flash it across the goal.
77mins
Pienaar plays Baines in behind the City back four and as the full back comes onto the pass he goes down and Everton appeal for a penalty but Alan Wiley was unmoved.
74mins
Robinho breaks from deep and surges at the Everton defence ghosting past Neville and Osman before striking at goal but Howard saved well.
72mins
Elano is booked and is very lucky to stay on the pitch.
72mins
A contested drop ball sees Cahill take man and ball on Robinho and the ball breaks for Pienaar and Elano seeks retribution for the drop ball and flies through the back of Pienaar in a disgusting challenge.
70mins
Vincent Kompany and Tim Cahill come face to face after a seemingly innocuous incident in the penalty area. Another off the ball incident and a petty argument between two players. Alan Wiley only gives the players a talking to.
68mins
Gosling gives the ball away to Caceido who breaks through with Robinho and Elano in support. Caceido decides to take the shot on but Howard saves and Robinho isn't happy with his team-mate, he felt Caceido should have passed.
67mins
Phil Neville is booked for his tackle on Elano.
67mins
Alan Wiley cautions Nedum Onouha for his reaction to Phil Neville's foul.
66mins
Phil Neville brings down Elano on the wing and Nedum Onouha reacts to the challenge rather unnecissarily. A bit of handbags from the two defenders there.
64mins
David Moyes may be regretting the decision to make three changes and Everton will play with ten men for the rest of the game.
63mins
Phil Jagielka has gone down and appears to be in a lot of pain after twisting his knee. He has been stretchered off and Everton will be down to ten men now.
60mins
Dan Gosling also comes on to replace Castillo in the midfield.
60mins
Another like for like swap up-front as James Vaughan comes on for Louis Saha.
60mins
Three changes for Everton as David Moyes throws caution to the wind. Fellaini is replaced by Tim Cahill.
56mins
Gelson Fernandes comes on for Richards. Kompany will drop into defence with Onouha moving out to right-back.
56mins
Jagielka starts an Everton move that ends with Hibbert crossing from the right hand side to find Jagielka who had continued his run into the box but the defender heads the ball over from close range. A chance to get back into the game goes begging.
54mins
Micah Richards appears to have hurt himself in making the clearance that set that counter-attack on its way. He has hobbled off and there will be a change to come.
53mins
EVERTON 0-2 MAN CITY. Micah Richards launches a clearance to Caceido who turns the ball onto Robinho. Robinho picks out the run of IRELAND racing through and controls well before rolling the ball past Howard to find the corner.
53mins
A very positive start to the second period from Everton as they control possession and the tempo of the game. Hibbert crosses towards the back post for Baines but he miscues the volley.
49mins
Good build up down the right hand side from Everton ends with Pienaar rolling the ball into Fellaini on the six yard box who shoots on the turn. The ball looks destined for the top corner but Given makes an outstanding save!
46mins
Pienaar forces a corner for Everton - Can they get themselves back on terms from the set piece? The delivery flashes across the front of the goal and it somehow beats the post after a feint touch from the head of Castillo. So close to an equaliser.
46mins
The second period gets underway at Goodison with Everton trailing to a Robinho goal.
45mins
Half Time: EVERTON 0-1 MAN CITY. The whistle goes for half time and David Moyes will certainly hope for improvement after the break. City have dominated play and Robinho's goal gives them a deserved first half lead after some inspiration from Elano.
43mins
Phil Neville works a clever overlap with Hibbert who fires in a cross to the front-post but Saha couldn't find the target with his header from in-front of the near post.
40mins
The tempo of the game has slowed after the goal. The visitor's will hope to keep their concentration at the back to see their lead through to half-time.
38mins
Man City have dominated the game and they finally lead. Everton haven't looked good in possession but they now need to respond positively to the disappointment of going behind.
34mins
EVERTON 0-1 MAN CITY. Elano picks the ball up deep and slides a pass into the run of Robinho one-on-one with Jagielka. ROBINHO skips past the defender and drives the ball low, left-footed through Howard's legs to find the goal.
34mins
Robinho looks a threat everytome he gets the ball at the moment. Hibbert looks uncomfortable defending against the record signing. A City corner ends in a bit of a scramble and De Jong shoots as it falls for him but his long rage strike goes wide.
32mins
The Everton midfield has looked a little disjointed in possession so far today. Perhaps the Toffees are missing their midfield duo of Arteta and Cahill but City are yet to punish any of the mistakes so far.
29mins
Pienarr finds space outside the visitor's box and the winger turns the ball onto his right-foot and tries his luck but fires well wide. Worth an effort from there!
28mins
Caceido brings the ball down from a long clearance and he turns the ball into Robinho and the winger plays an excellent ball into the run of Ireland but just as he looks to strike Baines comes back with a perfectly timed challenge.
24mins
City craft their first chance as Bridge gets to the byline and the ball fells for Elano. The first strike is blocked by Yobo but it comes back for the Brazilian who looks to find the corner but Howard makes a superb save to deny the opening goal.
22mins
A dangerous position for Everton from a set-piece that Baines will deliver but he does so badly and Ireland clears at the front post.
19mins
Again the Everton full-backs getting forward, this time its Hibbert overlapping down the right chipping the ball towards the back post for Fellaini but Richards leaps to flick the ball away from the tall striker. Good defending.
15mins
Elano drives the ball into Robinho on the left hand side and the winger cuts inside but his shot is comfortable for Howard. A good run from Baines on ends in a low cross that needs a crucial interception from Onouha to clear the danger.
14mins
Positive build up play from Everton as Saha runs into the channel behind Richards after a pass from Fellaini. The ex-United man tries a cross with his right foot but can only drive the ball into the hands of Shay Given.
11mins
Robinho finds space on takes on Hibbert but then squares to find De Jong on the edge of the box and the Dutchman tries the shot but gets it all wrong and sends it horribly wide.
10mins
Fellaini and Osman link up on the right hand side and Osman tries to thread the ball with the outside of his foot into the channel for Saha but its too firm and runs for a goal-kick.
7mins
Robinho gets the ball in a forward position and showed great skill to beat Hibbert but went down under the challenge. Alan Wiley saw no infringement and Everton are able to clear.
5mins
The ball is worked wide on the overlap into the path of Leighton Baines forward from left back. The delivery is good from Baines but Given did well to quickly come off his line and gather.
3mins
Everton have won an early corner after a long-ball towards Fellaini forces a mistake from Onouha - Pienarr delivers - The ball comes into the back post but Richards rises well to head clear.
0mins
Alan Wiley gets this North-West derby underway.
0mins
Caicedo continues up-front in place of the injured Bellamy. Wright-Phillips and Zabaletta are also missing from the City midfield so Ireland, Kompany and De Jong make up the three man midfield. Robinho and Elano will play off Caicedo in attack.
0mins
David Moyes is without the on-loan striker Jo as he is ineligible against his parent club so Saha starts up top. Fellaini starts despite concerns over an injury that ruled him out in midweek. Cahill is rested and Castillo starts.
0mins
Man City: Given, Richards, Onuoha, Dunne, Bridge, De Jong, Kompany, Elano, Ireland, Robinho, Caicedo.
0mins
Everton: Howard, Hibbert, Yobo, Jagielka, Baines, Osman, Neville, Castillo, Pienaar, Fellaini, Saha.
0mins
Hello and welcome to Goodison Park where an in form Everton side come up against a Manchester City side still chasing an outside chance of a European football next season.
Match Preview
Everton appear to be on course for a return to European football as they prepare to host Manchester City at Goodison Park.
Their midweek goalless draw with Chelsea consolidated their grip on sixth place in the table and they now have an eight-point lead over seventh-placed West Ham United with five games to go.
Manager David Moyes had warned his players against complacency before the trip to Stamford Bridge after the Toffees booked their place in the FA Cup Final - also against Chelsea - with a Wembley victory over Manchester United last weekend.
The Scot's words were certainly heeded as his players stepped up on Wednesday night. However, it will become more and more difficult to maintain focus on the league as the countdown to a first Final in 19 years gathers pace in the coming weeks.
Louis Saha is likely to be wrapped in cotton wool so expect Jo - who is ineligible for the FA Cup - and the fit-again James Vaughan to do most of the legwork up front as the season comes to a close.
Phil Jagielka and Tony Hibbert were rested against Chelsea but could return at the back, while England Under-21 international Jack Rodwell is pushing for a start.
City still have something to play for, as Mark Hughes' side could yet earn a return to the UEFA Cup, or the re-titled Europa League as it will be next season.
Last time out the Citizens won 4-2 at home to rock-bottom West Bromwich Albion, again mixing the sublime with the ridiculous.
Robinho finally scored for the first time since the turn of the year, while Elano is starting to look like the player who excelled when he arrived in England at the start of last season.
However, defensively City still look very shaky and Hughes is mulling over the chance to blood a few youngsters.
He told the club's official website: "There are a number of players who are very much in my thoughts.
"We still need to win Premier League games, that's important for us, but if the opportunity presents itself to blood a young player, we'll have a look at that."
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Manchester City ran out deserved 2-1 winners over a jaded ten-man Everton at Goodison Park.
A Europa League chasing City side arrived on Merseyside to face a buoyant Everton, still buzzing after cementing their FA Cup final place and holding Chelsea to a draw in midweek.
Everton could have easily recorded a big victory with a little more accuracy from City loan ranger Jo, who was missing from the line-up against his employers.
Segundo Castillo kept his starting place after his impressive game against Chelsea, while Moyes rotated his defence with Phil Jagielka replacing Joleon Lescott.
Pablo Zabeleta missed out through injury but otherwise Mark Hughes' side was unchanged from the team that beat West Brom convincingly last time out.
The game started tentatively with both midfields cancelling each other out. Robinho had a penalty shout waved away early on for City, while at the other end Steven Pienaar almost put Louis Saha through.
Robinho forced a smart tip over from Tim Howard on 25 minutes as he began linking well with Elano.
Castillo and Stephen Ireland were having a right old battle in midfield with one momentous tussle resulting in the ball falling to Pienaar, who delivered a pin point cross low into the box which Saha just failed to get a touch on to.
Leighton Baines effected a fantastic sliding tackle on Robinho to prevent a certain goal with the fleet-footed Brazilian through on Howard's goal.
Everton's reprieve was short-lived though as Elano played a lovely straight ball from midfield to Robinho, who twisted and turned to escape the attentions of Jagielka.
When this ploy failed the striker simply faced the defender head on and shot home past Howard with almost desultory ease to send the away fans into ecstasy.
Saha should have levelled minutes when Tony Hibbert delivered a perfect cross which the Frenchman contrived to head well over.
After the Toffees fantastic but emotionally draining week, Moyes would find it difficult to lift his team at half-time, while Hughes asked his boys for more of the same.
Everton forced a corner in the opening minute of the second half. Castillo's glanced header from Pienaar's kick rolled inches wide to the chagrin of the Goodison faithful.
Minutes later Marouane Fellaini almost scored a highly impressive equaliser as he received a low Pienaar cross, which he flicked up and caught on the turn, however Shay Given produced a great reaction save to palm clear.
Ireland added a second goal against the run of play as Felipe Caicedo played a short ball to Robinho, who floated a high ball over the Blues' defence to an unmarked Ireland, who made no mistake from eight yards out as he guided the ball past an onrushing Howard.
Moyes had seen enough by the 60th minute and hauled off Saha, Fellaini and Castillo for Tim Cahill, Dan Gosling and James Vaughan.
By 65 minutes though disaster struck as the inspirational Jagielka stretched for a ball as what looked like his right ankle gave way under him.
The defender was stretchered off and with all Everton's subs used it was down to a ten-man home side to attempt to claw back some kind of result.
The game was becoming increasingly bad tempered and after an altercation between Cahill and Vincent Kompany, Elano was lucky to only see yellow after an horrendous tackle from behind on Pienaar.
Deep into stoppage time Gosling pulled a consolation back for Everton as they piled forward, but City held firm to record only their second away victory of the season.
Everton Team
Manchester City Team
Everton | Manchester City |
Corners
| 5 | 3 |
Fouls
| 12 | 14 |
Goal attempts
| 12 | 16 |
Shots off target
| 8 | 6 |
Offsides
| 2 | 3 |



90mins
Corner from Pienaar is headed clear by Evans - Neville turns the ball back into the box but Given comes out to gather the cross.