skip to content

  • Date:29 Oct 2011
  • Kick-off:15:00
  • Venue:East End Park
  • Attendance:3,979
  • Kirk (54)
  • Dixon (12) Dalla Valle (17)
    Russell (74)
    Mackay-Steven (81)

Live Commentary

91:32 +1.32

The referee blows for offside against Stuart Armstrong. Indirect free kick taken by Paul Gallacher.

91:15 +1.15

The assistant referee flags for offside against Ryan Thomson. Jon Daly takes the indirect free kick.


Outswinging corner taken from the right by-line by Paul Burns, clearance made by Jon Daly.


David Graham takes a shot. Jon Daly gets a block in.


Inswinging corner taken by David Graham, Keith Watson makes a clearance.


Willo Flood takes a shot. Blocked by Paul Burns.


Outswinging corner taken by Gary Mackay-Steven from the left by-line, Jason Thomson makes a clearance.


Willo Flood fouled by Jason Thomson, the ref awards a free kick. Jason Thomson shown a yellow card. Free kick taken by Scott Allan.


Jon Daly handles the ball and concedes a free kick. The referee shows Jon Daly a yellow card for unsporting behaviour. Patrick Clarke has an effort direct from the free kick, blocked by Jon Daly. Gary Mackay-Steven grabs a goal from close in to the top left corner of the goal. Dunfermline 1-4 Dundee Utd.Assist on the goal came from Johnny Russell.


Stuart Armstrong on for Scott Robertson.


Patrick Clarke replaces Andy Kirk.


The ball is delivered by Paul Dixon, Johnny Russell takes a shot.


Willo Flood crosses the ball, save by Paul Gallacher.


Scott Allan takes a shot. Gary Mackay-Steven takes a outswinging corner to the near post, Johnny Russell scores a goal from close range high into the middle of the goal. Dunfermline 1-3 Dundee Utd.


Outswinging corner taken right-footed by Paul Burns, clearance by Jon Daly.


Outswinging corner taken left-footed by Gary Mackay-Steven, Header from deep inside the area by Gavin Gunning goes harmlessly over the crossbar.


The ball is swung over by Gary Mackay-Steven, Austin McCann makes a clearance.


Gary Mackay-Steven takes the outswinging corner, Jason Thomson makes a clearance.


The referee blows for offside against David Graham. Scott Allan replaces Ryan Dow. Dusan Pernis takes the indirect free kick.


The ball is delivered by Paul Dixon.


Steven McDougall is brought on as a substitute for Patrick Boyle.


Booking for Paul Burns. Outswinging corner taken from the right by-line by Willo Flood, save made by Paul Gallacher.


Paul Dixon delivers the ball, save made by Paul Gallacher.


Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Paul Burns by Scott Robertson. Austin McCann crosses the ball from the free kick left-footed from left channel, clearance by Gavin Gunning.


Ryan Dow sends in a cross, clearance by Austin McCann. Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Willo Flood from the left by-line, clearance made by David Graham.


Corner taken right-footed by Paul Burns, Dusan Pernis makes a clearance.


Handball by Gary Mackay-Steven. Alex Keddie takes the free kick.


Craig Easton goes off and Ryan Thomson comes on.


Johnny Russell produces a left-footed shot from just outside the area that goes harmlessly over the target.


The ball is swung over by David Graham, save by Dusan Pernis.


Andy Kirk finds the back of the net with a goal from inside the box to the bottom left corner of the goal. Dunfermline 1-2 Dundee Utd.


Centre by Austin McCann, Jason Thomson takes a shot. Dusan Pernis makes a save.


Outswinging corner taken from the right by-line by Paul Burns, clearance made by Keith Watson.


Andy Kirk challenges Ryan Dow unfairly and gives away a free kick. Gary Mackay-Steven joins the action as a substitute, replacing Lauri Dalla Valle. Jon Daly restarts play with the free kick.


A cross is delivered by Andy Kirk.


Centre by Jason Thomson, Jon Daly manages to make a clearance.


The official flags Johnny Russell offside. Indirect free kick taken by Paul Gallacher.


Ryan Dow takes a shot. Paul Gallacher makes a save.


Paul Dixon delivers the ball.


Ryan Dow crosses the ball, Keith Watson takes a shot. Save made by Paul Gallacher.


Shot from deep inside the area by Ryan Dow clears the crossbar.


Paul Dixon crosses the ball, blocked by Jason Thomson.


Keith Watson sends in a cross, save by Paul Gallacher.


Scott Robertson produces a right-footed shot from inside the six-yard box that clears the bar.


Craig Easton challenges Johnny Russell unfairly and gives away a free kick. Willo Flood takes the direct free kick.


Corner taken right-footed by Willo Flood, David Graham manages to make a clearance.


Keith Watson sends in a cross, blocked by David Graham.


The ball is crossed by Paul Dixon, Austin McCann manages to make a clearance.


Ryan Dow is adjudged to have handled the ball. Paul Gallacher restarts play with the free kick.


Paul Dixon produces a cross, Austin McCann makes a clearance.


Gary Mason challenges Johnny Russell unfairly and gives away a free kick. Gary Mason is sent off by the referee. John Rankin takes the free kick.


David Graham crosses the ball, Jon Daly manages to make a clearance.


Centre by Jason Thomson, Gavin Gunning makes a clearance.


Shot from just outside the box by David Graham misses to the right of the goal.


Lauri Dalla Valle finds the net with a goal from inside the six-yard box to the bottom right corner of the goal. Dunfermline 0-2 Dundee Utd.


Foul by Andy Kirk on Lauri Dalla Valle, free kick awarded. Paul Dixon takes the direct free kick.


Free kick awarded for a foul by Patrick Boyle on Lauri Dalla Valle. The ball is sent over by Willo Flood, Paul Dixon gets on the score sheet with a goal from inside the box to the bottom right corner of the goal. Dunfermline 0-1 Dundee Utd.


Corner taken by Paul Burns, Headed effort from deep inside the penalty area by Jason Thomson goes harmlessly over the crossbar.


Unfair challenge on Lauri Dalla Valle by Alex Keddie results in a free kick. Scott Robertson produces a shot on goal direct from the free kick, save by Paul Gallacher. Outswinging corner taken right-footed by Willo Flood, Alex Keddie manages to make a clearance.


Patrick Boyle sends in a cross, save made by Dusan Pernis.


Ryan Dow takes a shot from just outside the penalty area which clears the crossbar.


Foul by Lauri Dalla Valle on John Potter, free kick awarded. John Potter takes the free kick.

Match Preview

Easton: We're ready for United test Craig Easton expects to face a determined Dundee United side following their cup exit against Falkirk - but the Dunfermline midfielder has warned his former club that the Pars are intent on building on recent improvement. United manager Peter Houston publicly addressed reports he faced the sack in the wake of their penalties loss in the Scottish Communities League Cup. The Tayside club go into the game one point and one place above the Pars in the bottom three of the Clydesdale Bank Premier League, although the home side have not won since their triumph at Tannadice in August. But Easton has seen signs of improvement in recent weeks and Dunfermline deservedly ended a three-match losing streak with a late equaliser at Inverness last weekend. Easton feels United have been subjected to some harsh criticism, especially after losing talent such as David Goodwillie, Craig Conway and Morgaro Gomis in the summer. But he is eager to make life worse in the short term for his former team. Easton, who left United for Livingston in 2004 before a long spell in England, said: "They struggled the other night but it was a tough tie for them. I know they are getting a bit of stick but it was never going to be easy. "It will be a tough game for us. I'm sure they will want to put the cup tie behind them, so they will be right up for this. "We have to be ready for that, and I'm sure we will." The 32-year-old added: "When you have players doing really well, they are going to get snapped up by bigger clubs. "It doesn't help if you're trying to build a team. It's hard to compete with clubs in England and the wages. The boys who have left have all gone to big clubs in England. "But they have a lot of good youngsters coming through. We played them in a friendly recently and they looked pretty tidy. "We know what it's going to be like but we're confident we can get a result. "Hopefully we can make the same sort of start we made against Inverness but just get a couple of goals. "If we do that, we're confident we can get a result." A bullish Peter Houston has focused on preparing his Dundee United squad amid speculation about his future at the club. United have two SPL wins this season - the most recent on September 17 - and have lost five matches to sit two points off the bottom of the table in 10th place, but also two points behind sixth-placed St Mirren. Houston is yet to speak to United chairman Stephen Thompson about recent results, which included Tuesday's Scottish Communities League Cup quarter-final loss to Falkirk on penalties. Thompson is understood to have returned to the United Kingdom today after cutting short a family holiday and will hold discussions with Houston after the East End Park fixture. Turning the momentum around and winning at 11th-placed Dunfermline are Houston's focus and he hopes his side can show a response from the midweek defeat. He said: "We were expected to beat Dunfermline at Tannadice. We didn't (losing 1-0 on August 20). "Anything can happen. I'm quite sure Dunfermline will be thinking along the same lines. "They might be facing a wounded animal from losing the (Falkirk) match the other night - I hope they are. "What we have to do is don't feel sorry for ourselves, because we're out of the cup. "We need to make sure it acts as a spur to try and get a run of league games and get up the league." Following the Dunfermline fixture, United play Rangers, Hearts, Motherwell and Celtic, but Houston maintains belief he can stop the slide. He added: "We've got a very difficult run of games, but sometimes that's better than playing teams you're expected to beat. "We had a tough run of games last year and won seven or eight on the trot - a lot of people didn't expect us to go to Ibrox and win." Houston is first focused on the Pars and hopes his side's luck will turn, because morale is good. The performance of Johnny Russell, who scored United's opening goal on Tuesday, was one of the brighter aspects of Tuesday's loss and Houston hopes the striker can build on his display. Houston added: "He looked sharp and scored a good goal. He'll gain confidence from that." Russell could start tomorrow, but Houston has a number of injury concerns to undisclosed players. Sean Dillon (calf) remains out, but could return for next week's clash at Rangers, while Danny Swanson (knee) and Scott Severin (broken leg) are still absent. end

Formation:442Manager: Jim McIntyre


Formation: 442Manager: Peter Houston

Dundee Utd

  • Paul Gallacher
  • Jason Thomson
  • Alex Keddie
  • John Potter
  • Austin McCann
  • Paul Burns
  • Gary Mason
  • Craig Easton
  • Patrick Boyle
  • Andy Kirk
  • David Graham
  • SUBS
  • Chris Smith
  • Steven McDougall
  • Andy Dowie
  • Patrick Clarke
  • Paul Willis
  • Ryan Thomson
  • Kerr Young



Match Report

Terrors crush Pars Dundee United eased the pressure on under-fire manager Peter Houston with a 4-1 hammering of Dunfermline at East End Park. First-half goals from Paul Dixon and Lauri Dalla Valle gave United a comfortable advantage but Andy Kirk netted early in the second half to pull the home side back into it. However, late goals from Johnny Russell and Mackay-Steven secured victory for the visitors. It was understood before the match that Dundee United chairman Stephen Thompson had cut short a family holiday to hold talks with Houston after the match. The visitors enjoyed much of the early possession and created the first chance of the game when some neat build-up play led to Ryan Dow striking wide. Two minutes later Dunfermline goalkeeper Paul Gallagher was forced into an excellent low stop from Gavin Gunning's ferocious free-kick. United grabbed the goal their play merited after 13 minutes when Willo Flood's free-kick was only partially cleared allowing Dixon to unleash a fantastic left-footed drive into the bottom right corner. United doubled their lead five minutes later when Dixon's tame effort was deflected into the path of Dalla Valle who coolly slotted the ball beyond Gallagher. The home side created their first chance of the game after 22 minutes but David Graham's powerful shot was off target and their miserable start to the game continued when midfielder Gary Mason was shown a straight red card following a reckless challenge on Russell. The home fans were furious at referee Steve O'Reilly's decision but Mason appeared to have his studs raised in the tackle. United were well in command and continued to search for goals. Scott Robertson passed up a good opportunity after 35 minutes when he shot over from Dow's intelligent cut-back. It was the visitors who made the brighter start to the second half and in the opening minute Gallagher did well to stop Dow's shot from distance. Dunfermline came close to pulling a goal back after 50 minutes when Kirk's cross clipped the top of the crossbar, giving the home fans cause for optimism. United manager Houston made his first change of the game after 53 minutes when he replaced goalscorer Dalla Valle with Mackay-Steven. The home side grabbed an unlikely goal 10 minutes into the second half when Paddy Boyle won the ball in the midfield and set up Kirk who slotted the ball beyond Dusan Pernis. From there they began to grow in stature and Jim McIntyre introduced striker Steven McDougall in place of Boyle. But it was United who continued to create the better chances and they came close to grabbing a third goal when substitute Scott Allen's excellent run into the box forced Gallagher into an excellent stop. John Rankin almost turned the rebound in but Alex Keddie was on hand to bundle the ball out for a corner. With 16 minutes remaining United notched a crucial third goal when Russell took full advantage of poor defending from Mackay-Smith's corner to slam home from close range. Russell had a glorious opportunity to add to his tally minutes later when Dixon slid the ball across the penalty area but the midfielder struck the bar with his first effort and blazed the rebound over. With eight minutes remaining United secured victory with a fantastic piece of breakaway football. From a Dunfermline corner Flood released Russell and the midfielder's jinxing run ended with a cool pass to Mackay-Smith who tapped home a fourth.

Form Guide

  • Dunfermline
  • VS
  • Dundee Utd

Last Meetings

  • Dundee Utd
  • 0 - 1
  • Dunfermline
  • 20/08/2011
  • Dunfermline
  • 1 - 0
  • Dundee Utd
  • 21/04/2007
  • Dundee Utd
  • 0 - 0
  • Dunfermline
  • 27/01/2007
  • Dunfermline
  • 2 - 1
  • Dundee Utd
  • 18/11/2006
  • Dundee Utd
  • 0 - 0
  • Dunfermline
  • 19/08/2006
  • Dundee Utd
  • 0 - 1
  • Dunfermline
  • 02/05/2006

Top Scorers


  • A Kirk 3
  • J Cardle 2
  • R Thomson 2
  • M Hardie 1
  • P Burns 1
  • J Thomson 1

Dundee Utd

  • J Daly 6
  • D Swanson 3
  • L Dalla Valle 2
  • J Russell 1
  • G Gunning 1
  • G Mackay-Steven 1
  • B Douglas 1



    • Total goals 35
    • Goals per game 12
  • (For) 2 (Against) Period 0-10 mins
  • 1 (For) 2 (Against) Period 11-20 mins
  • 2 (For) 1 (Against) Period 21-30 mins
  • (For) 4 (Against) Period 31-40 mins
  • 1 (For) 4 (Against) Period 41-50 mins
  • 2 (For) 3 (Against) Period 51-60 mins
  • 2 (For) 1 (Against) Period 61-70 mins
  • (For) 3 (Against) Period 71-80 mins
  • 4 (For) 3 (Against) Period 81-90 mins

Dundee Utd

    • Total goals 38
    • Goals per game 15
  • 1 (For) 1 (Against) Period 0-10 mins
  • 1 (For) 4 (Against) Period 11-20 mins
  • 1 (For) 1 (Against) Period 21-30 mins
  • 3 (For) 3 (Against) Period 31-40 mins
  • 1 (For) 3 (Against) Period 41-50 mins
  • (For) 3 (Against) Period 51-60 mins
  • 3 (For) 2 (Against) Period 61-70 mins
  • 4 (For) 3 (Against) Period 71-80 mins
  • 1 (For) 2 (Against) Period 81-90 mins