skip to content

  • Kick-off: 15:00
  • Venue: Goodison Park
  • Attendance: 34155
  • Referee: Riley, M

Live Commentary

90mins

And the whistle goes! And what an amazing finish, goals in the 93rd and 94th minute give Everton all 3 points, and City will be broken after being so close to gaining a point.

90mins

James Vaughan breaks through the City defence, the defenders were never going to catch him, and the young striker finishes to put the game beyond doubt.

90mins

Lee Carsley provides a great strike after Everton expose the space, and Everton have taken a late late lead which could well win them the game.

90mins

Yakubu appears to be fouled, but the referee decides otherwise, much to the annoyance of the home fans.

90mins

There will be four minutes of stoppage time.

88mins

Gary McSheffrey shoots, but it is saved well by Howard, and the last couple of minutes have been tension filled.

86mins

Cahill sportingly plays the ball out with Garry O'Connor lying on the ground, but the home ground make their feelings known about Cahill's sporting gesture.

84mins

Thomas Gravesen replaces Steven Pienaar, who has had a very good game today.

83mins

Vaughan has a great shot on goal and is brilliantly blocked by Johan Djourou.

83mins

A very tense last 10 minutes in progress here, and both sides have made it clear of their philosophies with attacking substitutes after the goal.

81mins

James Vaughan replaces Leon Osman.

80mins

Kapo scores! City had the corner, and Kapo headed home powerfully to bring the scores level, and what a great finale we have to this game now.

79mins

Daniel de Ridder is replaced by Mikael Forssell.

78mins

Johan Djourou clears a Neville cross, and Neville struggles to get back at City break, and City need to go for it here with just over ten minutes to go.

75mins

City have a succession of corners, but they all come to nothing as a free-kick is awarded in the box for a foul.

73mins

Pienaar and Arteta link up well once again, but Pienaar's attempt on goal is easily blocked and City regain possession.

71mins

Medhi Nafti is replaced by Gary McSheffrey.

70mins

Lee Carsley has a great long range strike and it ends up on the roof of the net, and that came out of no-where!

66mins

The game is producing a lack of chances in the last 10 minutes or so, however Gary McSheffrey and Mikael Forssell are warming up on the sidelines to perhaps change that.

62mins

City, despite the close scoreline, aren't really creating those golden chances in front of goal, and at the moment Everton are certainly in the driving seat.

59mins

The ball bounces around the City box and Pienaar and Lescott both attempt a swing at the ball, but to no avail and the ball is eventually cleared.

57mins

Steven Pienaar goes down the wing and looks to link up with Arteta, but Kelly defends well and is able to clear the danger.

54mins

Garry O'Connor has certainly started brightly, he's playing like a man with a point to prove.

51mins

Garry O'Connor comes on to replace Sebastian Larsson as Bruce makes an early tatical change.

50mins

Cahill heads at goal from close range, but the keeper saves well, and Everton have gone up a gear here.

48mins

Yakubu runs through from a quick free-kick and smashes a shot right across the face of the goal, and once again, the quick free-kick cuts through City and Yakubu should have scored.

45mins

The second half gets underway, and City will be hoping that they can tighten up their back line after Everton continued to find and expose space in the City defence.

45mins

After a single minute of stoppage time, the whistle goes and Everton head into the break with a single goal lead, City though, have been improving as the half went on, and Bruce will be encouraged by that.

44mins

Neither side has shut up shop with the break approaching as both sides show attacking intent, but neither side, at the moment, can quite produce the goods.

42mins

Taylor comes out and saves well and releases the ball quickly as City break, but the move comes to nothing as Everton regain possession.

39mins

Kelly will have to watch himself now, Pienaar has been playing well down the Everton wing, and another rash tackle from the City player could now result in his dismissal.

37mins

Stephen Kelly is booked for a foul on Steven Pienaar.

34mins

Howard again fumbles at a relatively tame City shot, and that should be encouraging to City's strikers.

31mins

Everton once again break fast as Steven Pienaar shows good speed, and the Merseysiders are certainly on top once again.

28mins

City have a very long record of tasting defeat here at Goodison Park, and if City continue to play in this fashion, it seems that record will continue.

25mins

Taylor saves well and City did well to clear as Cahill was closing in to strike from close range, but City are defending very dangerously this afternoon, and its an issue that needs to be addressed.

23mins

Yakubu once again finds himself in space upfield, and Bruce wont be happy that the Everton striker keeps finding so much space.

21mins

Alan Stubbs is taken off and replaced by Phil Jagielka, the change suggests that Stubbs has taken a knock and cannot continue.

20mins

Cahill brings down Rafael Schmitz and a free-kick is awarded, both teams have shown signs of good play, and that will be encouraging to both managers.

17mins

Everton had been edging out City, but the away side have been getting back into this game and its pretty even at the moment.

16mins

Kapo has a great strike on goal, but the effort is saved well by Howard.

12mins

A dangerous ball is put in to the Everton box, the keeper spills it but no City attacker had made the gamble and the ball is then safely collected.

10mins

Ayegbeni Yakubu finishes neatly after he finds space in the box after City's slack defending is exposed, and Everton take an early lead.

7mins

Steven Pienaar latches onto a through ball and he strikes it well, but it is equally saved by Maik Taylor.

5mins

City seem to be slow out of the blocks today, Everton have been taking quick free-kicks and are catching out the Birmingham defence, and Steve Bruce will need to get his team in gear.

2mins

Everton break forward and Yakubu especially shows good play, and that's an early warning sign for City there.

0mins

Mike Riley is in charge for the game today, and the home side will be confident of a result as Birmingham have only won one of the last 28 league games here at Goodison Park.

0mins

Johan Djourou returns to the starting line-up but Palacios is not in the squad following family trouble back in his native Honduras as City start with:Maik Taylor, Kelly, Schmitz, Djourou, Ridgewell, De Ridder, Muamba, Nafti, Larsson, Kapo, Jerome

0mins

Phil Neville is back from suspension while Arteta recovers from a calf injury as both players start as the Merseysiders kick-off with: Howard, Neville, Yobo, Stubbs, Lescott, Arteta, Carsley, Osman, Pienaar, Cahill, Yakubu

Match Report

A damp squib of a game ended with a Bonfire weekend bang that put a sparkle in David Moyes' eyes.

But for an injury-time display of football fireworks, the Everton boss could easily have been ruing a host of missed chances as his lacklustre side almost allowed a poor Birmingham City team to salvage a draw.

Everton welcomed Birmingham to Merseyside after an impressive seven-day period that saw them halt their league slide, top their UEFA Cup group and make the quarter-finals of the Carling Cup.

Birmingham, for their part, arrived on the back of a decent win last week against Wigan that saw Steve Bruce's men halt a five-game losing streak.

Early on it became apparent that the Midlands side has come to Goodison not to lose, rather than aiming for a win, as the five-man midfield offered little in the way of service to lone striker Cameron Jerome.

The first real chance of the game came on eight minutes when Joseph Yobo slid in a second too late to convert Steven Pienaar's carefully-placed cross.

But Everton went ahead two minutes later when Yakubu finished-off a move that saw Mikel Arteta clip a cheeky pass to Pienaar, who ran into Maik Taylor's 18-yard area to supply the Nigerian with an inch-perfect pass to tuck home.

Indeed Birmingham's threat was almost non-existent in the first half, apart from a deflected long-range effort from Rafael Schmitz and a shot from Olivier Kapo which gave keeper Tim Howard little trouble.

After the goal, Everton continued to threaten only sporadically with South African Pienaar the main spark in attack.

Everton had chances to wrap-up the game in the first half, but by half-time the match had a tired feel and it seemed the Toffees had a lot to chew-over in the dressing room.

Yakubu almost doubled the home team's advantage in the opening minutes of the second period as his shot across goal from the deadball line rolled agonisingly wide.

Tim Cahill headed straight at the keeper a minute later and it seemed the Goodison outfit had stepped up a gear.

In the 53rd minute Birmingham brought on Garry O'Connor with Bruce switching to a straight 4-4-2 formation to try and wrestle something from the game and they immediately looked more threatening.

The Toffees appeared a little rattled as City started to gain possession in more advanced areas, though it was clear the real threat was still coming from Moyes' men.

Leon Osman, Arteta and Pienaar again all made futile attempts on Taylor's goal.

When Birmingham's equaliser arrived it was through a simple corner kick which substitute Gary McSheffrey whipped-in with pace for Kapo to rise and nod in.

Amazingly that seemed to light Everton's touch paper and, when the game was in injury time, Liam Ridgewell's clearance rolled into the path of Lee Carsley on the edge of Taylor's area.

The midfielder took one touch to control the ball and than unleashed an unstoppable drive that sent the home fans into raptures.

Forty-eight seconds later James Vaughan put the result beyond doubt when he tucked away Carsley's long headed return ball to finish the affair with a real bang.

Everton

Birmingham City

Corners

65

Fouls

1422

Goal attempts

167

Shots off target

71

Offsides

11

advertisement

advertisement