- Agbonlahor (85)
- Date:2009-09-13
- Kick-off:12:00
- Venue:St Andrews Stadium
- Attendance:25196
- Referee:Webb, H
Live Commentary
90mins
Birmingham 0 Aston Villa 1
90mins
Another unbelievable chance for Villa to make it 2-0 on the break and they'll kick themselves if they concede an equaliser now. Carew and Milner break and bear down on goal. Carew squares to Milner who'd have an open goal but the pass is over-hit.
90mins
Great chance for Agbonlahor on the break and he should make it 2-0. Young plays it to Agbonlahor beyond the Birmingham defence. He tries to chip Hart from the edge of the area, but it's over.
89mins
Birmingham are throwing everyone forward trying to press for the equaliser.
87mins
Pressure from Birmingham around the Villa penalty area, but they can't fashion a chance and Villa clear.
86mins
Birmingham substitution: Attacking change as Carsley comes off to be replaced by Phillips.
85mins
Birmingham 0 Aston Villa 1: Young plays the free-kick into the area and find s Carew who heads into the path of Agbonlahor who heads home from 6 yards out past Hart's right hand.
84mins
Parnaby blocks off the run of Young and is the first Birmingham man into the book. Free-kick to Villa 35 yards out on the right.
83mins
Benitez works space to shoot from the edge of the area but it's straight at Friedel. Benitez had Parnaby free down the left and should have used him.
82mins
Good play by Carew to hold the ball up and feed Milner down the left. He twists and turns on the edge of the area and finds space to cross, but it's straight at Hart.
80mins
Fine effort from Milner and it so nearly finds the bottom left corner of Hart's goal. Milner turned well and shot right-footed from 20 yards but it gets a nick off a defender and creeps wide of the post.
79mins
Birmingham substitution: O'Connor exits to be replaced by Benitez.
78mins
Great cross from the left by Warnock finds Sidwell at the far post. He gets his head to it, but it's straight at Hart who saves well at point blank range.
76mins
Cross by Milner is flicked on by Sidwell, but it's over Agbonlahor and there's no other Villa player in the area.
75mins
Decent looking deep cross from Young, but it's headed away.
73mins
Young cuts in well on his right foot 20 yards out. He finds space to shoot but it's way off target.
72mins
Good play down the right by Johnson. He plays in a low cross to the near post which is met by O'Connor but he can't quite flick it goalwards and it'll be a goal-kick to Villa.
71mins
Aston Villa substitution: Carew comes on for Reo-Coker in an attacking change by Martin O'Neill.
69mins
Free-kick to Birmingham 25 yards out on the left hand side as Milner catches Fahey late. Larsson takes right-footed but Dunne heads clear again.
66mins
Agbonlahor is adjudged to have fouled Queudrue as he tries to get away down the left and his comments earn him a yellow card from Howard Webb.
65mins
Birmingham work space for Larsson down the right but this time his cross isn't great and is headed clear.
63mins
Larsson does well to work half a yard down the right and earns his side another corner. Corner is outswinging and Dunne heads clear.
62mins
Good turn from Sidwell 30 yards from goal gives him space to shoot, but it's straight at the defender and safely away.
60mins
Another wasted ball from Milner out to Warnock as he plays it straight out for a throw-in to the home side. It's not been Milner's best afternoon.
59mins
Effort from distance again from Carsley. It's not enough to trouble Friedel as it drifts tamely wide, but Birmingham are starting to get on top in this game.
58mins
Cuellar is almost caught out letting a square ball run across his body on the edge of the area as Parnaby came flying in, but Cuellar stabs it away and the danger is averted.
57mins
Good cross from Milner on the right hand side towards Agbonlahor, but Johnson does well to head clear.
54mins
Decent effort from Carsley but Friedel is equal to it. Carsley picked the ball up 30 yards out, he shifted it onto his right foot before curling an effort towards Firedel's left hand post, but the American keeper holds on to it.
52mins
First yellow card of the game goes to Sidwell of Villa. Birmingham broke through half-way with Larsson and the Villa man just tugs him back. It's an easy decision for Howard Webb.
51mins
Milner does well to turn on half-way and find space, but his pass wide with the ouside of the boot is well over-hit and out for a throw-in. It's a real waste from the Villa man.
49mins
Good ball by Young looking for the pace of Agbonlahor over the top, but it' just intercepted. Agbonlahor was so nearly in on goal.
48mins
Larsson does well to dig out a cross from the right under pressure, but it's too long and can't find a team-mate.
47mins
It's been a much more settled start to this second half, but neither side seem able to maintain any spell of possesion.
46mins
Birmingham get the second half underway, looking to maintain their unbeatean home record.
46mins
Birmingham substitution: Carsley comes on for the injured James McFadden for this second half.
45mins
Both sides have shown plenty of endeavour and desire, but it's tight and tense and neither side have really created enough to justify getting themselves in front.
45mins
Birmingham 0 Aston Villa 0
45mins
There will be 2 minutes of added time in this first half.
45mins
Milner crosses well from the right and finds Agbonlahor. He tries to head it goalwards at the near post, but it goes wide. Referee Webb gives a goal-kick but it looks to have taken a deflection of a Birmingham defender.
43mins
Young attacks down the right, trying to wriggle free of 3 defenders to get a cross in, but Queudrue comes across and nicks it away for a throw-in. McFadden has gone down injured holding his knee and it looks at though he may struggle to continue.
41mins
Free-kick is taken short t oYoung. He sends in a right-footed cross which beats everybody in the centre and reaches Milner at the far post, but he can't adjust his feet quick enough and puts it wide from a few yards on a tight angle.
40mins
Young beats Tainio down the left, going across the half-way line, but Larsson comes across to foul him. It's a free-kick to Villa.
38mins
Bowyer attempts a one-two with Parnaby on the edge of the Villa area, but his pass is a bit wayward and it's out for a goal-kick.
35mins
The free-kick is taken short to Young, but it's well read and he loses possession and the chance is wasted.
34mins
Foul by Tainio on Young in a dangerous position 30 yards out in line with the left-hand edge of the area.
32mins
Villa play a short free-kick to Milner on the half-way line and he's allowed to run almost unchallenged to the edge of the Birmingham area, but his left-footed shot is tame and wide for a goal-kick.
30mins
Good flick on by O'Connor gets Bowyer in on goal, but he doesn't have the pace to get away from Collins and has to take the shot early. It's on target but Friedel turns it comfortably wide for a corner.
28mins
Poor communication between Dunne and Friedel and the former City defender concedes a corner.
27mins
Decent hold up play by Agbonlahor in the right corner of the pitch allows Milner a chance to send in a cross. It's a dangerous looking ball but it ricochets about in the box, before deflecting out for a goal-kick off of Reo-Coker.
26mins
Ball played forward down the left by Bowyer looking for O'Connor, but it's just too long and out for a throw-in.
25mins
Good possession by Birmingham in the Villa half, but the play breaks down and it comes to nothing.
21mins
Good ball forward by Petrov, finds Agbonlahor running into the right-hand channel. He crosses low to Milner, but his side footed effort from 15 yards is well off target. Milner will feel he should have done much better with that opportunity.
18mins
Ball played in to the Villa penalty area by Parnaby looks for Larsson, but it's just too high for the Birmingham man and drifts harmlessly away at the far post.
17mins
Good attack from Villa. Agbonlahor finds space on the edge of the area. he plays it left to Milner, who cuts back in on his right foot but his shot is easily charged down.
16mins
McFadden advances down the left and tries to play it into the path of Bowyer but there's a misunderstanding between the two and the ball goes straight to a Villa player to end the attack.
14mins
It's been a pretty high tempo opening quarter of an hour to this game and neither side have really got on top with any settled passage of play.
12mins
Free-kick to Birmingham again on the right-hand side 35 yards out. Larsson takes and this time finds Ferguson but he heads over.
10mins
First half chance for the home side. Shot from O'Connor was well blocked. The ricochet fell to Larsson inside the area but his shot was charged down again.
9mins
Foul by Young on Tainio 35 yards out on the right hand touchline and it's a free-kick to the hosts. Larsson plays it in, but it's poor and easily cleared.
7mins
First half chance of the game. Agbonlahor does well down the left channel to outmuscle Tainio. He comes inside and lays it to Milner 15 yards out but he rushes the shot under pressure and puts it wide.
6mins
Good run from Larsson down the right for Birmingham. He crosses early into the box, but there's no Birmingham player making the penalty area and the ball is headed clear.
4mins
Tackle from behind by Ferguson and Larsson, sandwiching Agbonlahor on the half-way line. It's a free-kick to Villa and Howard Webb justs takes a second to calm things down.
3mins
Long ball forward from Queudrue down the left hand side, but it's overhit and out for a goal-kick.
2mins
It's been a frantic start from both teams, players from both sides quick to the tackle and possession being turned over quickly.
1mins
The visitors get this game underway.
0mins
Birmingham, however, are unbeaten in their last 10 league games at St Andrews, dating back to January 2008, when they were beaten 1-0 by Chelsea.
0mins
Villa won the last league fixture between the sides 5-1 and have claimed victory in the last four encounters.
0mins
Tainio takes his place in the Birmingham line up this afternoon, having recovered from a calf strain suffered on international duty.
0mins
Aston Villa team line-up: Friedel, Cuellar, Dunne, Collins, Warnock, Milner, Sidwell, Reo-Coker, Petrov, Young, Agbonlahor
0mins
Birmingham City team line-up: Hart, Tainio, Johnson, Queudrue, Parnaby, Larsson, Bowyer, Ferguson, McFadden, Fahey, O'Connor
Match Preview
Birmingham City host fierce rivals Aston Villa on Sunday in what promises to be a typical high octane Midlands derby.
Blues boss Alex McLeish knows that bragging rights are very important and will be looking to get one over on counterpart Martin O'Neill at St Andrew's.
Unfortunately for McLeish, he has several injury problems ahead of the game with Cameron Jerome (ankle), Gregory Vignal (hip), Marcus Bent (hamstring), Martin Taylor (foot), Scott Dann (thigh) and Liam Ridgewell (broken leg) all notable absentees.
City have made an indifferent start to their Premier League campaign after their one-season stay in the Championship.
Their home form is solid with a 1-0 win against Portsmouth and a 0-0 draw with Stoke City. On the road though they have lost both games, but with home advantage, they will be looking to further consolidate their place in mid-table.
The Villains will not want to fall at their near rivals' feet and the shrewd O'Neill will be pulling out all the stops to come away with a win.
He has to choose from a squad that is without Curtis Davies (dislocated shoulder), Luke Young (thigh) and Stewart Downing (foot) who are all missing for the foreseeable future. The game may also come too soon for defender Wilfred Bouma (ankle).
The two foes last met in the Premier League during the 2007-08 season and, at St Andrew's, Villa walked away with a 2-1 victory.
Former Villa defender Liam Ridgewell scored an own goal to put his former employers in front before Mikael Forssell equalised on the hour.
However, with the game heading towards a draw, livewire centre-forward Gabriel Agbonlahor turned the screw in the 87th minute to cash in and take the three points to Villa Park.
In the return clash, Villa resoundingly beat Birmingham 5-1 with Ashley Young scoring twice in between a John Carew brace before Forssell pulled one back.
Agbonlahor added a fifth late on to prove a thorn in City's side once again.
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Gabby Agbonlahor's 85th-minute goal helped Aston Villa snatch a vital local derby win to the utter frustration of Birmingham City.
Agbonlahor's second goal of the season was Villa's one real goal opportunity of the game which summed up a tense battle.
Birmingham could certainly feel hard done by at the end of a match in which they had more of the attacking play than Villa.
It was certainly a much-improved local derby performance from Birmingham but they could not prevent themselves slipping to their fifth successive defeat against their old rivals.
Birmingham demonstrated their recent good form with a positive performance as they were always prepared to attack.
As a result Villa, who included three new signings, Richard Dunne, Stephen Warnock and James Collins, were unable to build up many attacking moves.
The raw tenacious approach of Birmingham put Villa out of their stride and it was significant that Ashley Young, without the service usually provided by Nicky Shorey, was unable to operate as freely as usual.
James Milner had Villa's best chances in the first half from openings created by Agbonlahor but on each occasion the England man was off-target.
Birmingham were similarly restricted. Garry O'Connor managed to fire off a vicious left-foot shot only to see his effort deflected in turn by Dunne and Warnock.
A great deal of credit for Birmingham's battling performance can be attributed to the likes of Barry Ferguson who has really settled to life in the Premier League following his arrival from Rangers.
Franck Queudrue and Roger Johnson also played a major role in the heart of Birmingham's defence which was the reason for Villa's limited goal opportunities.
James McFadden was unable to resume for the second half because of a leg injury and was replaced by club skipper, Lee Carsley - the only Birmingham-born player in the home side.
A helter-skelter type of game continued after the break, and when the industrious Seb Larsson did break he was pulled back by Steve Sidwell who was booked by Howard Webb for his transgression.
Larsson, making his 100th league appearance for Birmingham, could not be faulted for effort and his strong running did much to keep the Blues in the match.
It was not until the final 15 minutes that Villa suddenly applied pressure and Joe Hart distinguished himself with a close-range save to keep out a header from Sidwell.
The only goal occurred after Stuart Parnaby had been booked. Young's free-kick was headed on by substitute John Carew to the unmarked Agbonlahor who guided the ball past Hart.
Birmingham City Team
Aston Villa Team
Birmingham City | Aston Villa |
Corners
| 7 | 1 |
Fouls
| 10 | 20 |
Goal attempts
| 11 | 12 |
Shots off target
| 4 | 7 |
Offsides
| 0 | 3 |



90mins
Free-kick to Birmingham 25 yards out. Karsson takes but it's deflected out for a corner.