- Collins (11)
- Milner (60), Barry (80 pen)
- Date:2009-01-17
- Kick-off:15:00
- Venue:Stadium of Light
- Attendance:40350
- Referee:Dean, M
Live Commentary
90mins
FULL-TIME: SUNDERLAND 1-2 ASTON VILLA. Villa have produced a superb comeback, despite going down to ten men, to steal all three points when it appeared they were in for an afternoon of disappointment after Sunderland's fine first-half display.
90mins
Superb block from Gardner! Andy Reid is played in by Whitehead but just as he pulls the trigger, Gardner slides in from nowhere to get his body in the way.
89mins
Carlos Edwards runs at Luke Young now and gets past him to the byline to drill the ball into the box but Friedel flies out to claim.
88mins
A long ball is looped in by Andy Reid and Kenwyne Jones gets a flick on but Brad Friedel is out to collect before Cisse can latch onto it.
86mins
The hosts are flying at Villa now as they throw the ball long towards the penalty area to try and force something.
85mins
Teemu Tainio collects a booking.
83mins
No wonder Sunderland were so angry when the referee awarded the penalty! Replays suggest that McShane caught Agbonlahor outside of the penalty area and it should have only been a free-kick.
81mins
El-Hadji Diouf is replaced by Andy Reid.
81mins
SUNDERLAND 1-2 ASTON VILLA. Gareth BARRY steps up and smashes the ball striaght into the back of the net without hesitation and Villa lead.
80mins
Fulop picks up a booking for failing to retreat to his line at the penalty.
79mins
Penalty! Agbonlahor sprints towards the box with a bouncing ball and McShane comes in with a high foot and referee Dean points straight to the spot.
77mins
Villa look to be incredibly frustrated now and Agbonlahor collects a yellow card.
75mins
Suddenly Sunderland look like the side that started this game as they begin to knock it around in midfield and get Diouf and Cisse into the game.
72mins
Craig Gardner is on for Steve Sidwell as Martin O'Neill tries to alter his side's shape a little to a 4-4-1.
72mins
Ashley Young is now dismissed for a woeful over-the-top challenge on Dean Whitehead. A shocking tackle and that could have a big effect on Villa's challenge today and this season.
70mins
Villa are smashing against the Sunderland door now but they are meeting with stubborn resistance.
67mins
Ashley Young is starting have an influence now as he runs at his full back before drifting a superb ball to the far post where Sidwell is inches away from connecting.
65mins
Gareth Barry curls a delightful free-kick towards the far post and Cuellar rises highest to meet it and force a good save from Fulop once more.
63mins
The onslaught is on from the visitors now and Sunderland are starting to fall further and further back and are only rarely threatening to break out.
61mins
Paul McShane has been recalled from Hull this week and he is on now in place of Nosworthy.
61mins
Danny Collins is going off the field now and Phil Bardsley is coming on in his place.
60mins
Replays suggest that the ball certainly hit Milner on the chest before possibly skipping into the corner off his shoulder.
58mins
SUNDERLAND 1-1 ASTON VILLA. Superb play from Ashley Young as he drives to the byline and pings a cross in that MILNER bundles home off some part of his upper body - it may have been his arm.
57mins
Whitehead steals the ball off Sidwell in midfield and slips a clever ball in behind for Kenwyne Jones who fires straight at Brad Friedel.
56mins
Sunderland are trying to take the sting out of this at the moment because they can see Villa are starting to up the ante - but for now they can't create.
53mins
Djibril Cisse is the third name in the book for a challenge from behind on Milner.
51mins
Villa have clearly had an earful at the break from their manager as they have really upped the tempo since the interval.
48mins
A bright start from Villa after the break and Milner is involved again as he jinks away from Tainio before Collins is forced to bring him down.
46mins
The second period is underway and it will be interesting to see how things pan out.
45mins
Half-Time: SUNDERLAND 1-0 ASTON VILLA. The hosts got off to a blistering start and took a deserved lead through Collins but Villa are just starting to find their rhythm and create openings of their own.
45mins
There will be one minute of added time.
44mins
Nyron Nosworthy collects a yellow card for a foul on Agbonlahor.
43mins
The Black Cats are looking a little nervous as they find themselves under the cosh as half-time approaches and Villa are growing in confidence.
41mins
Almost the equaliser! Diouf gives away a free-kick in shooting range and Young works a clever one with Petrov to find room for a screaming shot that shaves the outside of the post.
38mins
However, other Villains are trying to step up to the plate today with Petrov now crossing deep to the far post for Agbonlahor but Fulop comes out again to flick it off the striker's forehead.
36mins
Chimbonda, Nosworthy and Ferdinand are doing a superb job of cutting out the service to Young and Agbonlahor.
33mins
Nigel Reo-Coker is bursting forward with great gusto this afternoon from right-back and he gets to the byline again to drive a cross into the box and Fulop takes a good claim with Agbonlahor waiting to pounce.
31mins
When Sunderland apply pressure, they really apply pressure! Edwards delivers four corners back-to-back as Villa struggle to clear their lines. Eventually Ferdinand has a header at goal that skims the top of the net as it goes over.
29mins
It's starting to become a bit end-to-end now at the Stadium of Light as Villa become a threat but it is Reo-Coker and Milner causing the problems. Sunderland look dangerous on the break still.
26mins
Super save! Cisse holds the ball up well to roll it into the path of Whitehead who hits a fierce drive that Friedel does brilliatnly to finger-tip wide of the post.
24mins
The visitors are starting to find their rhythm as Barry, Sidwell and Petrov keep possession and begin to dictate the tempo but so far they have been unable to really create anything of note.
20mins
We are yet to see anything of Villa's dynamic duo of Ashley Young and Gabby Agbonlahor but Sunderland's version of Cisse and Diouf are causing endless problems at the other end.
18mins
Luke Young collects the first booking of the day and it is no surprise that it comes for a foul on Diouf.
17mins
Sunderland are continuing to press on with Kenwyne Jones the latest to test Brad Friedel with a decent driven effort from the edge of the box.
13mins
The home crowd are vey loud now as they continue to celebrate their side taking the lead. This will be a real test of Aston Villa's credentials!
11mins
SUNDERLAND 1-0 ASTON VILLA. Opening goal! Probably deserved on the balance of play but the scorer is unexpected as Danny COLLINS rises highest to meet Carlos Edwards' free-kick and power a header past Friedel.
10mins
Mistake from Chimbonda as he lets Milner steal the ball off his foot and the winger drives to the box to curl a superb cross to the far post where Ashley Young is inches away from making contact.
7mins
El-Hadji Diouf is giving Luke Young a torrid time early on as he keeps beating the stand-in Villa left-back to the byline to fire dangerous crosses into the box.
5mins
Villa look sluggish and Sunderland are really trying to take advantage with a bright start as they get in amonsgt the Villa midfield and defence.
3mins
A penalty shout! Sunderland have half a shout at a penalty as Barry slices Cisse's cross onto the arm of Petrov but the referee is not interested.
1mins
Mike Dean is the man in charge today and he gets us underway on Wearside.
0mins
Aston Villa: Friedel, Reo-Coker, Davies, Cuellar, Luke Young, Milner, Sidwell, Petrov, Barry, Ashley Young, Agbonlahor
0mins
Sunderland: Fulop, Chimbonda, Nosworthy, Ferdinand, Collins, Edwards, Tainio, Whitehead, Diouf, Cisse, Jones
0mins
If the Black Cats are going to take anything today they need Nosworthy, Chimbonda, Ferdinand and Collins to get a handle on the movement of Ashley Young, Milner and Agbonlahor.
0mins
Aston Villa are most definitely in the Champions League race and may feel that the title is within their grasp if Arsenal are still considered to be contenders.
0mins
Sunderland have only been beaten once in their last five Premier League games but have only won one of their last five on home turf.
0mins
Welcome to the Stadium of Light where Sunderland host Champions League chasing Aston Villa.
Match Preview
High-flying Aston Villa travel to Sunderland on Saturday with the chance to cement their place firmly in the top four.
Sunderland sit in 13th place going in to the clash at the Stadium of Light and mathematically could finish the weekend from anywhere in the top half to in and around the relegation zone.
Meanwhile, Villa are still within sight of league leaders Liverpool, leading Arsenal by three points in the race for a Champions League spot.
Martin O'Neill's side have not suffered a domestic loss since early November and are relatively healthy.
The only injury concerns for the visitors will be John Carew (back) and Wilfred Bouma (ankle). It is unlikely that either will return in time for the trip to the north-east.
Villa will pin their hopes on December's Barclays Player of the Month Ashley Young and the in-form James Milner to propel them to victory.
Milner has been catching the eye of late, scoring twice at Gillingham in the FA Cup, while Young has been one of the Premier League's form players this season.
Ricky Sbragia has settled a sinking ship at the Stadium of Light over recent weeks, picking up points to nudge the Black Cats up the table.
The Sunderland chief will hope to be able to call on goalkeeper Craig Gordon following an ankle injury, while fellow goalkeeper Darren Ward is expected to remain on the sidelines with a back problem.
George McCartney is set to return to training following surgery on a foot injury, but is a few weeks away from match fitness while Steed Malbranque is suspended after accumulating five bookings this term.
Sbragia has been busy this month shipping players out of the club as he looks to cut an oversized squad.
However, he has insisted that Northern Ireland international David Healy has an important part to play for his team and the striker could figure this weekend.
Sbragia said: "I've told David I don't want him to go. I know what he can do, I know he will pop up and score goals.
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Aston Villa kept alive their chase for a Champions League spot as two controversial goals secured victory at the Stadium of Light.
The Villans, however, won't mind how their smash and grab raid was achieved especially as they finished the game with only ten men.
The defeat was a bitter blow for Ricky Sbragia's Sunderland and there is no doubt the manner of the two goals will have been a sore point for the Wearsiders.
The hosts had started the brighter of the two sides, going on the attack from the kick-off, a move that almost paid off as early as the second minute.
The Black Cats won a corner out on the left and well the ball came it appeared to hit Stiliyan Petrov on the arm. However referee Mike Dean waved away appeals for a penalty.
It wasn't the last time Dean was to have a say in the proceedings, the man in the middle twice giving Villa the benefit of the doubt in front of goal.
The first came on 59 minutes as Ashley Young broke down the right and crossed into the Sunderland six-yard box.
The onrushing James Milner was already grounded and met the ball with his arm to steer it into the net. Despite protests, Dean allowed the goal to stand.
It offered Villa a way back into a match, which despite their possession and quick attacks, looked like it may evade them.
Sunderland were quite clearly the better side in the first half and deservedly went in front after 11 minutes. A foul by Curtis Davies on Kenwyne Jones saw the Black Cats awarded a free-kick some 40 yards out from goal in a central position.
Winger Carlos Edwards clipped the ball towards the box and Danny Collins rose unmarked to nod home past Brad Friedel.
The hosts almost doubled their lead on 26 minutes as El-Hadji Diouf played in Dean Whitehead. The Sunderland skipper's low shot bringing a good save out of Friedel.
After that Villa started to press more and the Wearsiders invited unnecessary pressure on themselves as they sat far too deep.
That led to a sustained spell of possession for Villa, but for all their time on the ball the visitors never tested home keeper Marton Fulop in the opening half.
Villa did, however, go close on 41 minutes Ashley Young curling a free-kick just wide of Fulop's right-hand post.
Sunderland again started brightly after the break and seemed to be coping with the Villa threat before Milner's leveller.
Villa stepped things up after that, but were rocked by Ashley Young's straight red on 71 minutes, the winger deservedly receiving his marching orders for a two-footed lunge on Whitehead.
However a wasted chance by Djibril Cisse, the Sunderland striker heading straight at Friedel, proved the catalyst for Villa's winner.
The visitors broke quickly and caught Sunderland substitute Paul McShane napping.
The Irishman was the wrong side of Gabriel Agbonlahor and caught the Villa forward in the face with a high foot as he raced in on goal.
There was no doubting the foul, but there were questions over whether or not Agbonlahor was offside and whether the foul was outside the box.
Referee Mr Dean had no hesitation in pointing to the spot, despite being some 30 yards away when the incident occurred.
Up stepped Villa skipper Gareth Barry to send Fulop the wrong way and seal a 2-1 win for his side.
The hosts tried to get back into the game, but their efforts came to nothing as Martin O'Neill's side held firm.
Sunderland Team
Aston Villa Team
Sunderland | Aston Villa |
Corners
| 8 | 6 |
Fouls
| 14 | 17 |
Goal attempts
| 9 | 5 |
Shots off target
| 3 | 1 |
Offsides
| 3 | 0 |



90mins
Late penalty shout for Sunderland! Edwards drives to the byline and tries to cross but it is blocked by the arm of Young, however referee Dean deems it not enough for a penalty.