- Dunne (15)
- Bellamy (68)
- Date:2009-10-05
- Kick-off:20:00
- Venue:Villa Park
- Attendance:37924
- Referee:Dean, M
Live Commentary
90mins
ASTON VILLA 1-1 MAN CITY.
90mins
Villa do well to break down the City counter, can't see a winner in all honesty, the again - famous last words...
90mins
Five minutes of added time, can someone break the deadlock and secure all three points??
90mins
City nearly nick a winner as Bellamy's cross finds Santa Cruz but he can't find the target and his effort goes wide.
89mins
Cuellar clears Bellamy's free kick.
88mins
Petrov wins a free kick in the middle of the pitch after he was brought down by Barry.
85mins
Petrov clears Bridge's cross, the pace has left the game somewhat, it would be a shame but perhaps they're both content with a point.
82mins
Ashley Young mkes way for Nigel Reo-Coker, his first appearance since that spat with Martin O'Neill.
80mins
Both sides are going for this one, we're in for a great finish.
78mins
Milner's cross takes a lucky deflection and falls for Petrov but the Villa man swings wildly and misses the ball completely - a let off for City.
77mins
Young's cross from the left nearly finds Milner but Bridge does well to get there first and deny the Villa winger the chance to shoot.
75mins
City are pressing now and Friedel has just done well to race out of his goal and claim Ireland's pass before Adebayor could get to it.
72mins
Villa were looking good value for the win before that slick counter, with just under 20 minutes to go there could well be a winner in this one.
68mins
John Carew Makes way for Emile Heskey for Villa.
68mins
Carlos Tevez makes way for Roque Santa Cruz for City.
67mins
ASTON VILLA 1-1 MAN CITY. A great counter attack is finished off by Craig BELLAMY who slots the ball home from six yards from Adebayor's pull back.
67mins
Friedel claims Bellamy's cross.
65mins
City win their third corner but the Villa defence finally manage to scramble the ball clear.
64mins
City win two corners in a row as they look for the equaliser.
61mins
Agbonlahor wins Villa a corner after outpacing Toure.
59mins
Dunne again beats Barry to a cross but this time he heads wide of the goal.
58mins
Shaun Wright-Phillips is booked for a foul on Stephen Warnock, seems a bit harsh to me it wasn't a malicious challenge.
55mins
Good defending from Toure as he beats big man John Carew to James Milner's cross.
54mins
Collins and Cuellar team up to stop Wright-Phillips in his tracks as he attempted to get forward for City.
53mins
Villa looking the brighter of the two sides at the moment, I wouldn't be surprised if Tevez made way for City some time soon, he hasn't been particularly effective tonight at all.
52mins
Ashley Young must have noticed Capello in the stands as he tracks back to deny Zabaleta the chance to cross, great effort from the Villa winger.
51mins
Nigel de Jong makes way for Stephen Ireland for City.
50mins
Milner shoots powerfully from a tight angle but his shot just flashes across the goal and goes out for a goal kick, decent effort from the former Leeds youngster.
48mins
Barry crosses towards Adebayor but the City striker can't reach it.
47mins
Ashley Young seems to have shrugged off that knock he took at the end of the first half, which is good news for Villa fans and England boss Fabio Capello who is in the stands.
46mins
The second half is underway in the West Midlands.
45mins
ASTON VILLA 1-0 MAN CITY.
42mins
Barry delivers a great cross towards Adebayor, the City striker sends a powerful header goal-wards that Friedel does well to tip over the bar.
42mins
City are the side pushing as we head towards the break but Villa are standing firm, this will be a massive three points for whoever takes them and it has been a very enjoyable first half.
41mins
Looks as if Young was hurt after de Jong's challenge, he is receiving treatment.
38mins
Nigel de Jong is booked for a challenge on Ashley Young.
36mins
Barry delivers a wicked corner into the Villa box which Toure nearly gets too but Villa clear their lines.
34mins
City are applying the pressure but Villa are defending well, having said that this is an open game with chances at either end and I'm sure we'll see some more goals this evening.
32mins
Tevez tries his luck from range again and this time forces Friedel to make the save, it would take something very special to beat the American from there though.
31mins
Villa's Stiliyan Petrov is shown the yellow card for a foul on Wright-Phillips.
29mins
A quick Villa free-kick allows Petrov the chance to drill in a low cross but Wright-Phillips clears the ball for City.
27mins
Sidwell's shot is easily saved by Given in the City goal.
25mins
City are fighting to get back into this one and Carlos Tevez has just seen two efforts from range go wide in quick succession.
23mins
Great defending from Warnock, Barry skips past Dunne and was about to unleash a shot when the Villa defender nicked the ball away from his feet inside the penalty area.
17mins
Just what Villa don't need, they're guilty of some sloppy play after taking the lead as Cuellar misplaces his pass under no pressure to give City possession.
15mins
ASTON VILLA 1-0 MAN CITY. Former City man Richard DUNNE rises above Gareth Barry and head James Milner's corner past Shay Given, some sections of the away crowd are even applauding their former skipper.
13mins
Bellamy, who is having an excellent season for City, plays a neat one two with Bridge before the Villa defence cut his pull back out with Adebayor lurking, that was a vital interception.
11mins
Cracking effort from Villa's Stiliyan Petrov, Ashley Young fed him the ball and Petrov had a go from 30 yards, his effort had Given beaten but his shot was just wide of the target
8mins
City step it up a bit, they would as soon as I'd said Villa were looking better, Wayne Bridge's cross is defelected over the bar then Adebayor heading into Friedel's arms moments later.
6mins
Agbonlahor is caught offside as Villa look to get forward, they've looked the better of the two sides in these opening minutes.
4mins
Tevez places a neat pass to Wright-Phillips who bursts into the Villa penalty area but he's penalised for running into former team mate Dunne.
2mins
Carew wins Villa a corner, good start by the home side who are chasing City down from the off, Milner swings the corner in and Gabby Agbonlahor pokes it goalwards only for Given to save it with is legs.
0mins
The game is underway at Villa Park.
0mins
Mixed reception for Barry from the home fans when his name is read out, some have cheered some have booed, the City fans on the other hand gave a massive cheer for Dunne.
0mins
City have scored 14 goals in 6 games this season - 2.33 goals per game for all the stat fans out there - but they come up against the league's meanest defence, Martin O'Neill's men have shipped just five goals and have only conceded twice at home.
0mins
A lot of pre-match talk may have focused on Barry but Villa defender Richard Dunne is also facing his old employers for the first time, while Steve Sidwell replaces Fabian Delph in the Villa starting eleven after recovering from an injury problem.
0mins
In other City team news Emmanuel Adebayor returns from his 3 match ban, Roque Santa Cruz is on a strong City bench after returning from injury.
0mins
Gareth Barry returns to Villa Park for the first time since his £12m switch to City, the former Villa captain spent twelve years with the club and I'm sure he'll be fired up for this one.
0mins
Man City: Given, Zabaleta, Lescott, Toure, Bridge, De Jong, Barry, Wright-Phillips, Tevez, Bellamy, Adebayor. Subs: Taylor, Richards, Sylvinho, Ireland, Johnson, Petrov, Santa Cruz
0mins
Aston Villa: Friedel, Cuellar, Dunne, Collins, Warnock, Milner, Petrov, Sidwell, Ashley Young, Agbonlahor, Carew. Subs: Guzan, Delph, Heskey, Reo-Coker, Shorey, Beye, Gardner.
Match Preview
Aston Villa face big-spending Manchester City on Monday night as Martin O'Neill's men aim to cement their place amongst the European qualification places.
England striker Gabriel Agbonlahor has rediscovered his fine goalscoring capabilities and after scoring four in his last four games.
Fellow internationals Ashley Young and James Milner are impressing on either flank and they will be looking to show their worth to England boss Fabio Capello ahead of next week's World Cup qualifier against Ukraine.
Up until Saturday's disappointing 2-1 reversal at Blackburn Rovers, Villa had won their last six games - four in the Premier League, one against Rapid Vienna in the UEFA Europa League qualifying round and against Cardiff City in the Carling Cup - so confidence should be high.
Manchester City beat West Ham United 3-1 last Monday and they themselves should be looking to consolidate their place in the upper echelons of the Premier League.
Mark Hughes, with his embarrassment of riches in front of him, can now call on fit again Roque Santa Cruz who will be pushing for a start.
The Citizens have made an excellent start to their campaign and sit in fifth place on 15 points.
Their only defeat came in the Manchester derby against fierce rivals United a fortnight ago when they lost out to Michael Owen's last-gasp heatbreaker in the 4-3 epic.
With Carlos Tevez in the goals against his former club last time out, Hughes' strikers are starting to hit form.
The impressive Craig Bellamy will also be delighting Hughes, while Emmanuel Adebayor should be available following his three-match suspension for his antics against his former club Arsenal last month.
Last season the two sides opened their Premier League campaigns at Villa Park and it was the hosts who walked away with the spoils in a 4-2 victory.
John Carew opened the scoring at the start of the second half before Elano equalised from the spot.
Then young Villa star Agbonlahor turned the game on it's head as he hit a nine minute hat-trick.
Vedran Corluka notched in the final moments as Villa started the season in fine style.
advertisement
advertisment
Match Report
Richard Dunne scored Aston Villa's only goal against his old club to pave the way to a well earned point at Villa Park.
Star-studded Manchester City, with their host of top quality players, didn't have it all their own way and it wasn't until the 68th minute that fiery Welshman Craig Bellamy notched the equaliser to cancel out Dunne's 16th minute strike.
Gareth Barry had a mixed reception upon his return to Villa Park but he played a leading role in City collecting a point in a hard fought match.
With Emmanuel Adebayor back for the first time since his three match ban City were looking to the former Arsenal striker to spearhead another impressive performance.
Yet it was City who had a scare in only the second minute when Shay Given had to make a desperate block to keep out a clever flick by Gabby Agbonlahor from Ashley Young's corner.
The feature of the early play was the fast pace of the game with City always moving forward in menacing style.
But there was a dramatic development in the 16 minute. James Milner won a corner on the right and from Stephen Warnock's inswinging kick Dunne, who had shrugged off the attention of Barry, headed Villa into the lead with great purpose and personal satisfaction.
The response from City was positive with Carlos Tevez, playing well behind Adebayor, the main danger as he demonstrated with a long range drive which took a deflection only for veteran Brad Friedel to make a comfortable save.
City turned up the heat and it became a major concern for Villa how easy they were penetrated by some snappy moves often including four or five players.
Fortunately for Villa, Dunne was in outstanding form and he was given solid support by James Collins.
But it took another fine Friedel save to keep out a header from Adebayor following an accurately placed corner by Barry.
Surprisingly, City's defence was not as secure as it should have been as highlighted when Dunne narrowly failed to add to his tally from a Milner corner.
Barry, seemingly aided by the introduction of Stephen Ireland, then began to come more into the game setting up several good attacks but Villa were in no mood to surrender their slender lead as they doggedly defended in depth.
Villa, however, could not survive indefinitely and in the 68th minute Welsh international Craig Bellamy collected a pass from Adebayor to rifle his shot past Friedel.
Aston Villa Team
Manchester City Team
Aston Villa | Manchester City |
Corners
| 6 | 6 |
Fouls
| 10 | 8 |
Goal attempts
| 12 | 9 |
Shots off target
| 6 | 2 |
Offsides
| 4 | 0 |



90mins
Friedel gathers Wright-Phillips cross, two minutes left...