• Date: Sat 16 January 2010
  • Venue: Goodison Park
  • Ref: Marriner, A
  • Attendance: 37,378


Pienaar (36)

Saha (45) P

2 - 0

Everton vs Manchester City

Team Lineups


Tim Howard
Leighton Baines
Johnny Heitinga
Sylvain Distin (Seamus Coleman, 70)
Diniyar Bilyaletdinov
Tim Cahill
Phil Neville
Steven Pienaar
Marouane Fellaini
Louis Saha (James Vaughan, 85)
Landon Donovan (Jose Baxter, 90)

Manchester City

Shay Given
Micah Richards
Pablo Zabaleta
Javier Garrido
Martin Petrov (Mwaruwari Benjani, 46)
Gareth Barry
Vincent Kompany
Nigel de Jong
Roque Santa Cruz (Robson de Souza Robinho, 9)
Carlos Tevez
Craig Bellamy

Match Report
Steven Pienaar and Louis Saha were the heroes as Everton defied the form-book with a comfortable 2-0 win over Manchester City. Roberto Mancini's side headed into the Everton clash on the back of five consecutive victories but an impressive first-half display from the Toffees was enough to secure the three points. The diminutive South African Pienaar bagged the first after 36 minutes with a curled free-kick before Saha made it two on the stroke of half-time. Everton piled the pressure on their big-spending opponents from the first whistle and might have taken the lead after 26 minutes but Shay Given was equal to Diniyar Bilyaletdinov's left-footed half-volley. But the home fans didn't have to wait much longer for their opening goal with Pienaar's measured 20-yard free-kick doing the damage. Former Manchester United frontman Saha was brought down by Pablo Zabaleta and Pienaar curled the free-kick through a hole in the wall and past Given. And on the stroke of half-time Saha made it two from the spot. Micah Richards was adjudged to have pulled Saha's shirt and the Frenchman made no mistake from the spot. Tim Cahill should have extended Everton's lead on 46 minutes when he headed just wide from Phil Neville's long throw. City almost scored from an impressive counter-attacking move after Shaun Wright-Phillips picked up the ball from an Everton corner and started a move that ended up with Craig Bellamy firing wide. Bellamy then sent Gareth Barry scampering clear on 74 minutes but his cross from the left was comfortably taken by Tim Howard. Everton might have had three when Marouane Fellaini's thumping header was touched on to the crossbar by Given. And the dominant Toffees hit the woodwork again late on when Cahill headed against the post from Leighton Baines' cross.
Live Text Commentary
Full time

City suffer their first defeat under Roberto Mancini. They were well-beaten today by an Everton team that was excellent in all areas.


17-year-old Jose Baxter comes on for Landon Donovan.


Three minutes of stoppage time will be played.


City push forward in the search of a dramatic finish, but they again run out of ideas - the visitors have created very little today.


Pablo Zabaleta is nut-megged by Leighton Baines, soon after Bellamy was beaten by a fine piece of skill by Fellaini - Everton's fans are enjoying the close to this match.


Everton win yet another corner. Baines delivers but City manage to clear at the near post.


James Vaughan comes on for Louis Saha.


An inch-perfect cross by Baines is met firmly by Cahill, but the bar denies him - Everton have hit the woodwork three times in this second half.


City's brief resurgence has petered out - Everton are finishing stronger.


Marouane Fellaini forces Given into a sharp save from the resulting corner, the City keeper pushing the header onto the bar.


A Landon Donovan corner falls to Steven Pienaar on the edge of the area, but Kompany deflects behind.


A Diniyar Bilyaletdinov cross loops onto the City crossbar, but Given had it covered.


Time is running out for City, who are gradually improving, but it appears to be too little too late. They have been second-best today.


Sylvain Distin is replaced by Seamus Coleman.


City lazily lose possession in their own half and concede a corner as Donovan's cross is deflected behind. City clear the corner.


A better spell for City nearly ends with a chance for Bellamy, but the final pass is not good enough.


Wright-Phillips threatens to break in Everton's half, but Phil Neville makes a well-timed challenge.


Landon Donovan is tripped by Bellamy, but Andre Marriner keeps his cards in his pocket.


Substitute is substituted - Robinho is replaced by Shaun Wright-Phillips.


The match is lacking the tempo of the first half - the onus is on City to go on the attack.


There is a delay as Steven Pienaar receives treatment for a head injury after a collision with Micah Richards.


The Toffees have a succession of throw-ins down the City right and Baines' cross nearly causes problems at the near post, but City clear.


Javier Garrido whips in a free-kick from a dangerous area, but the delivery is poor and the ball drifts straight out.


Everton start the second half well, as City struggle to impose themselves.


Gareth Barry nearly releases Craig Bellamy, but Leighton Baines does well to intercept.

Second half

The second half gets underway.


Roberto Mancini makes a half-time change, Martin Petrov making way Benjani Mwaruwari.

Half time

The half-time whistle goes soon after the penalty is scored. City need to improve dramatically after the break.


Saha smashes the spot kick down the middle of the goal and Everton get a deserved two goal lead.


Penalty to Everton! Louis Saha is fouled by Micah Richards.


Two minutes will be added. Bellamy latches onto a Nigel de Jong throughball and forces Howard into a good fingertip save - a warning for Everton.


City have a spell of possession, but they make little impression in Everton's half. The visitors will be happy for the half-time whistle to go.


Cahill chests down perfectly for Bilyaletdinov, whose stinging shot flies just wide. Everton are attacking at will and should have a larger lead.


Tim Cahill has a good chance to get that goal, but Kompany got the tackle in as the Australian dwelled on the chance.


Everton are in total charge of this match - they need a second goal to show for their dominance.


A stunning free-kick by Steven Pienaar gives Everton a deserved lead. He got that over the wall and in off Given's righthand post.


City cannot keep hold of possession, not helped by the fact Tevez is limping after returning to action.


Everton win a corner after Phil Neville bursts forward. Fellaini, back on the field, heads the cross back across goal, but Vincent Kompany heads clear.


Everton's five-man midfield is winning the battle in the middle of the pitch.


Everton are gradually getting on top, Bilyaletdinov the latest player to try his luck - his scorching effort flies just over.


Fellaini and Tevez are both off the field with knocks, but they should be fit to return.


Marouane Fellaini does well to control and shoot on the edge of City's area, but his shot flies wide.


Everton get their first corner as Donovan's shot is deflected behind. Nigel de Jong clears.


Saha plays in Donovan in an inside right channel and the American's chipped effort beats Given, but the ball drifts wide of the target. The best chance so far.


City continue to move the ball quickly and accurately - they are playing with confidence and freedom under their bew boss.


Louis Saha should also do better at the other end, mis-hitting a chance straight at Given.


Robinho has a chance to shoot from Pablo Zabaleta's cross, but the Brazilian scuffs his effort.


Petrov nearly releases Tevez, but Sylvain Distin intervenes to concede a corner.


This is a lively start at Goodison - Landon Donovan, making his home debut, crosses for Diniyar Bilyaletdinov, the Russian's header lacks power and Shay Given makes a regulation save.


Tim Howard is forced into the first save of the match as Martin Petrov cuts in from the left to let fly.


Santa Cruz cannot continue, so Robinho enters the fray.


The hosts have not really got into this match yet, despite having a numerical advantage - Santa Cruz is still off the field receiving treatment.


Craig Bellamy combines well with Tevez down the Everton right, but the attack fizzles out.


Roque Santa Cruz is struggling after getting an early knock.


The in-form Carlos Tevez makes an early burst forward, but he is crowded out by two Everton defenders. City have settled quickly.


Play gets underway at Goodison Park.

Awaiting Kickoff

City know they can strengthen their hold on fourth place after Spurs and Liverpool dropped points earlier today, but they have won only one of their last 10 matches at Goodison Park.

Awaiting Kickoff

Roberto Mancini brings in Roque Santa Cruz for Benjani Mwaruwari, whilst David Moyes drops Lucas Neill, who is on his way out of the club, and Leon Osman, Sylvain Distin and Diniyar Bilyaletdinov the players to come in.