Manchester City v Manchester United: Community Shield player ratings

By Rory Smith 7:26AM BST 08 Aug 2011 Comments Manchester City Joe HartCould do little about any of United's goals and, despite the champions' greater share of possession, actually had little else to do. 6/10 Micah RichardsEmbroiled for much of the afternoon in an intense duel with Ashley Young, the City defender was as solid and reliable as ever. 6 Vincent KompanyThe Belgian is growing in stature as the rock around which City are built, but it was his uncharacteristic error which allowed Nani to score the winner. 6 Joleon LescottA curious game. The former Everton defender looked out of his depth early on, somehow rescued City twice and then opened the scoring. 7 Related Articles