Great results against Liverpool and Manchester City have been matched by poor performances too and while some players continue to excel, others have struggled to find their best form.
Before Christmas, we invited Everton fans to have their say in our half-term vote about the serason so far - and you replied in your hundreds. Here are the results - as always, we'd love to get your views in the comments.
1. Who is your Everton FC player of the season so far?
Although several members of the Everton first-team squad picked up votes, two players stood out - Tim Cahill with 32% of the vote and Leighton Baines, the EFC player of the season so far, with a colossal 48% of all votes cast.
That support was just reward for two goals and a bagful of assists in the first half of the season.
Biggest disappointment? >>>>>