Former Coventry City midfielder Kevin Thornton scored his first goal back for Nuneaton.
Thornton was on the mark in the 25th minute for Nuneaton at Conference North League Leaders Hyde who equalised through Crowther in the 36th minute.
Leamington drew 0-0 with Brackley.
In the FA Trophy, Bedworth United beat Market Drayton 2-1 with goals from Piggon and Robinson
Rugby Town need a replay after drawing 1-1 at home to Sutton Coldfield thanks to a Hamilton equaliser in the 76th minute.
Stratford Town beat Coleshill 3-1 in a Midland Alliance game.
More to follow