Terry Pierce - Plymouth on the brink of extinction
Published: 08 Feb 2011 - 09:46:38
Countless times over the last decade or so there have been tales of financial mismanagement in football. Stories of clubs on the brink of extinction, going in and out of administration, players not getting paid and the Football League handing out huge points penalties are far from rare.
- Download the Football.co.uk FREE iPhone and Android apps
Yet someone - be it a supporters' trust, a local consortium or a mysterious foreign owner - always saves the day. But one day there will be no one there to bail a club out and a Football League side will go out of business. The day may be approaching, and the club may be Plymouth Argyle.
Plymouth have been struggling financially for a number of seasons, but their relegation to League One combined with a high wage bill, plummeting crowds, the failed World Cup bid and false-dawn foreign ownership have left the club teetering on the brink.
Before Christmas the Pilgrims were issued a winding-up order by HMRC and were handed a 63-day period of grace by the courts. That adjournment concludes on Wednesday, and Argyle must return to court to pay the latest instalment of their agreement with HMRC.
Advisor Peter Ridsdale has suggested the club will be in a position to make the payment despite the failure of the club's majority shareholders - Japan-based Yasuaki Kagami and George Synan - to keep a promise of a £2 million investment.
A combination of player sales, cost-cutting and a £300,000 loan from the Plymouth Argyle Supporters Training and Development Trust will allow the club to make the payment and live to fight another day. But Ridsdale will cut all ties with the club in response to Kagami and Synan's failure to invest, and the former Leeds Chairman has said that the club needs to find further monies if they are to see out the season and fulfil their fixtures.
Argyle's playing staff have not been paid January's wages, the third month in succession they have gone without their salaries, while a fans group managed to raise more than £2000 to help pay non-playing staff's December pay-packets.
The club is doing everything it can to raise cash. The January transfer window saw a number of players, including top scorer Bradley Wright-Phillips and talented young winger Craig Noone, sold. But another fund-raising avenue, a buy-back scheme that would have seen Plymouth City Council re-purchase Arglye's Home Park before leasing the ground back to the club was vetoed by the council, leaving the club with little option other than to continue to desperately hunt for new investment.
Ridsdale has suggested the club are at a very early stage of negotiations with a number of interested parties but, alongside cash, time is not a luxury Argyle currently possess. If investment from their Japan-based owners is not forthcoming, it does appear to only be a matter of time before Plymouth face administration and the continuation of the downward spiral.
The HMRC may be paid for the time being, but without Kagami's investment the club will struggle to reach the summer afloat. With their best players sold to meet the HMRC's bill, and the ones remaining at the club unpaid and struggling for form, on the pitch the future looks bleak for Peter Reid's side, and they are now firmly entrenched in a battle for League One survival.
But all of that is inconsequential to the long-suffering Pilgims fans. They are doing everything they can to help, but without hard cash finding its way from East Asia, the very existence of the club looks perilous.
Follow me on Twitter @telpierce
- FOOTBALL.CO.UK BLOGGER:terry pierce
- Terry was born and bred in Wiltshire, and is a massive Swindon fan - travelling the length of the country most weekends to watch the 'mighty' Reds. He also manages a successful(ish) Sunday league side, and his life pretty much revolves around football. Five-year-old Terry was in the crowd when Swindon won promotion to the Premier League in 1993 with a 4-3 play-off win against Leicester. He cried after every goal. Read Terry's thoughts every week on life outside the Premier League. Follow Terry on Twitter @telpierce.
Previous Blog Posts
- A busy Easter in the Football League
- Momentum the key for Reading, Rochdale and Stevenage
- Why Martin Allen was right to dump Barnet for Notts County
- Swindon set to complete unthinkable fall from grace
- League Two strugglers set for very different futures
- Gradi achievements rightfully recognised
- Millwall crowd trouble highlights FA incompetence
- Stadium move inspires Chesterfield success
- High-flying Swansea destined for the Premier League
- Scunthorpe and Sheffield United set for six-pointer
- 5 Football League volleys to rival Rooney's
- Plymouth on the brink of extinction
- Transfer window winners and losers
- Boothroyd's honeymoon period comes to an end
- Championship new-comers find their feet with ease
- Macclesfield mourn yet again
- New year, new start for Championship strugglers
- Football League managers' Christmas wish-lists
- Unconvincing Keane on the brink at Ipswich
- To boo or not to boo - that is the question
- Milan Mandaric: Hero or villain?
- Ferguson Junior calm under pressure
- Bothroyd England call-up confirms Capello's madness
- AFC Wimbledon v MK Dons: The real story
- Seagulls flying towards promotion
- Clinical Cardiff ooze Premier League class
- Boro meltdown started with the sacking of Southgate
- League One made the most of the limelight
- Leicester may regret welcoming Cirque du Sven
- Malky Mackay's youthful Watford are buzzing
- Marlon King returns to the last-chance saloon
- Sensible Burnley show others how it's done
- Hope: Lifeblood of the tortured football fan
- Southampton will regret Pardew sacking
- Warnock fits the bill for QPR
- There's more to life than football
- Portsmouth deserve to be punished
- Championship season preview
- League One Season Preview
- League Two season preview
- World Cup 2010 never caught fire
- European challenge on the ropes
- Groundhog day for England
- Gerrard must play central role for England
- No fear for Millwall in the Championship
- Cardiff fans have reason for optimism
- The beauty of the play-offs
- Leeds hold their nerve to get over the line
- Wednesday are in far better shape than Palace