Joe Strange - James is the right man for the biggest stage
Published: 14 Jun 2010 - 08:13:39
For some players, pressure can be the catalyst for a truly special performance. For others, it can be the sole reason for their downfall.
Robert Green is a decent goakeeper, but on Saturday evening he cracked under the strain.
To be a success on the international stage, particularly when you're an Englishman, you need to be able to deal with the demands of having an entire nation on your shoulders.
And that's no exaggeration. On Saturday evening the whole country came to a standstill in expectation of a comfortable win over the United States.
And while the game was far from a walk in the park, the fact remains that we still should have come away with three points.
Green's mistake, while being completely unforgiveable, didn't come as much of a surprise to me.
Although he had a reasonably solid season with struggling West Ham, the former Norwich stopper has shown on a number of occasions that he's got a mistake in him.
Yes, the same can be said of most keepers, even David James and Joe Hart, but Green has consistently displayed his inconsistency, often mixing the sublime and ridiculous in the space of just a few minutes.
Despite having only 13 caps for the Three Lions he's already been sent-off, having seen red against Ukraine during the qualifying campaign for South Africa 2010.
Add to his unpredictable form a failure to deal with the big occasion and you have a recipe for disaster.
Along with his major error, Green's display was punctuated by hesitation and poor distribution - it was as if all he was thinking about was the millions glued to their televisions at home, rather than what was going on in front of him.
Experience is key in football, especially in tournaments as vital as FIFA's showpiece. And along with his questionable ability, Green just doesn't have the knowledge and understanding that comes with a long international career.
For me it's got to be David James in goal against Algeria. His nickname might be 'calamity' but by all accounts he is the back-four's preferred choice.
He might but pushing 40, but with age comes experience and an ability to deal with the big occasion.
Green might be good enough for a West Ham side struggling at the wrong end of the table, but an England goalkeeper he definitely is not.
READ JOE STRANGE EXCLUSIVELY AT FOOTBALL.CO.UK
- FOOTBALL.CO.UK BLOGGER:joe strange
- A product of Brighton University's prolific youth system, Joe Strange has boundless energy and the enviable ability to cover every blade of grass in his Monday blog. Joe has written for a variety of football websites and fanzines and is also a regular contributor to golf.co.uk. Despite being born and raised in Kent, 'Stranger' is a diehard Everton fan and counts his team's penalty shoot-out victory against Manchester United last season as his most memorable football moment. Follow Joe on Twitter @joe_strange.
Previous Blog Posts
- Carling Cup final shakes 'Mickey Mouse' tag
- Jack Wilshere comes of age against Barcelona
- Liverpool and Newcastle risk it all on deadline day
- Darren Bent could prove a shrewd investment
- Does anyone care about the FA Cup?
- Five predictions for 2011
- Everton prove you can't buy team spirit
- Glory glory Tottenham Hotspur
- Carroll set for career-defining England bow
- West Ham troubles show no sign of stopping
- Liverpool crisis is far from over
- Same old England, always boring
- Wenger's morals threaten Arsenal future
- Mancini is the right man for City's revolution
- Hand Chelsea the title now
- Everton v United was a modern day classic
- Rooney allegations are no surprise
- Arteta could have been an England legend
- Sweet revenge for Newcastle
- Ian Holloway is a genius
- Capello has lost the plot
- Bring on the Premier League
- My World Cup XI
- Suarez proved footballers do have brains
- Do-or-die time for England
- Spain are still favourites
- James is the right man for the biggest stage
- World Cup stage set for a King
- Why England will win the World Cup
- Top five Premier League signings of the season
- Portsmouth proud despite defeat
- Ferguson handed Chelsea the title
- Super Frankie Lampard
- Relegation class of 2010 will be long gone
- Is this the greatest Premier League season
- Portsmouth deserved their fairytale
- Manchester United are a one man team
- Ten reasons Zola has to go
- Chelsea confidence is key
- Wayne Rooney has come of age
- Aston Villa are in the ascendancy
- A dark weekend for the Premier League
- Fearless Everton are filthy rich in belief
- Soap opera on the south coast
- Why six clubs deserve to be relegated
- John Terry was already tarnished
- Magic of the Cup is alive and well
- Arsenal reveal their mean streak
- Chelsea prosper as rivals freeze