The Antagonist - Benitez tactics undermine Liverpool challenge
Published: 23 Oct 2009 - 09:11:44
It doesn't seem to matter how often it is suggested to Rafael Benitez that zonal marking from dead ball situations is 'pants', the 'Stubborn One' continues to implement this outdated, fault-ridden practice and Liverpool continue to suffer the inevitable consequences.
Statistically, up to and including last weekend's fixture with Sunderland, Liverpool stand at the top of a very unenviable Premier League table. That is, of all goals conceded (13), a staggering 77% (10) have been from set pieces.
Compare this with the champions, whose count, so far, is 0%, and you begin to see part of the reason why a seven point gap has opened up at such an early stage in the season.
Pundits and journalists from all corners have been castigating Liverpool's defensive arrangements since last season but, despite all their exhortations to amend his strategy and the increasingly powerful statistical evidence available to him , Rafa has remained stoic; anally retentive of his zonal system.
Maybe, he has observed that the successful Liverpool sides of the late 1980s employed this system with remarkable success.
However, for one reason or another, it doesn't seem to be working for the current Anfield incumbents who appear, at times, worryingly uncertain of their responsibilities.
So what are the main drawbacks of this method of territorial tactic?
Firstly, there will always be a blurring of what constitutes each players 'zone'. If an attacker runs between two defenders, whose responsibility is he?
A 'cute' striker will zig-zag in and out of zones to confuse the defenders. You can also have a scenario wheretwo orthree players all enter one players zone.
Is that defender then responsible for all of them? Secondly, an attacker running on to the ball will always have an advantage, in terms of momentum and surprise, over a fairly static defender.
Thirdly, in a man-to-man system, contact before the kick is taken, in terms of feeling or 'gently' holding an attacker by the defender (illegal of course but apparently now an accepted part of the game) allows the defender to 'sense' when the attacker is going to make his move and he can move with him.
Of course, even a man-to-man set-up is not a foolproof method of defending set pieces, but is a tried and tested formula that has stood the test of time and makes each player personally responsible for a specific opponent.
So, come on Rafa, swallow your pride, look at the figures and change the system before it's too late.
If you had employed a man-to-man system last week, the beach ball could have been carted into row Z by it's marker seconds before it had adroitly deflected Darren Bent's shot into the far corner.
Subsequently, the copious column inches taken up since, discussing the interpretation of Law 5, would have been rendered an irrelevance, and you wouldn't have had to spend the rest of the match with a face like a bulldog chewing a wasp!
- The Antagonist
READ THE ANTAGONIST EVERY FRIDAY EXCLUSIVELY AT FOOTBALL.CO.UK
- FOOTBALL.CO.UK BLOGGER:the antagonist
- Love him or loathe him you cannot ignore the Antagonist. His Friday blog tackles the big issues in our game today in an abrasive, often controversial style. He goes where others fear to tread. From wages to wags, diving to drugs - no subject is "off limits", no individual beyond reproach. Miss him at your peril!
Previous Blog Posts
- Horror injuries more than justify footballer wages
- Tabloid trashing could be the making of Rooney
- Rooney and Pietersen are battling the same demons
- Defoe joins the ranks of footballing cheats
- My 2010-11 season wish list
- Money talks this summer
- Football might never come home
- Why we need more Maradonas
- World Cup 2010 has been anything but predictable
- ITV have been hammered by the Beeb
- England are a long way from world-beaters
- England fans find perspective
- Victory against the USA should be a formality
- Five steps to avoid England heartbreak this summer
- Domestic demands have ravaged England
- The lull before the storm
- The madness of Fabio Capello
- Pressure is the lifeblood of the Premier League
- No surprises in the Premier League
- Two very different Champions League deaths
- Unpredictable season leaves the title up for grabs
- Zola was doomed from the start
- Chelsea count the cost of complacency
- Arsenal and United touched on perfection
- Why football should scrap the offside rule
- Why Bullies are good for football
- League football is not fast food
- The England team are a universally flawed bunch
- Football is in danger of financial implosion
- The England squad is in tatters
- No football like snow football
- Petty FIFA must stop tweaking the rules
- New Year Resolutions
- Arsene Whinger is still number one
- Potter Pulis calls the kettle black
- Get ready for the World Cup bore draw
- David Beckham can breathe easy
- Match of Hate ends in handshakes
- Player naming rights are surely next
- Why football is a waste of time
- Spitting in football is an artform
- Benitez tactics undermine Liverpool challenge
- The mystery of club ownership in the Premier League
- What is it with diving in football?